JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG

WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL RICHARD E GERSTEIN JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG. THIS BLOG IS DEDICATED TO JUSTICE BUILDING RUMOR, HUMOR, AND A DISCUSSION ABOUT AND BETWEEN THE JUDGES, LAWYERS AND THE DEDICATED SUPPORT STAFF, CLERKS, COURT REPORTERS, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS WHO LABOR IN THE WORLD OF MIAMI'S CRIMINAL JUSTICE. POST YOUR COMMENTS, OR SEND RUMPOLE A PRIVATE EMAIL AT HOWARDROARK21@GMAIL.COM. Winner of the prestigious Cushing Left Anterior Descending Artery Award.

Wednesday, October 24, 2018

3RD DCA JNC SENDS TEN NAMES TO THE GOVERNOR FOR TWO OPEN SEATS .......


THE CAPTAIN REPORTS:

YOUR TWO NEW 3RD DCA JUDGES .... WILL BE NAMED FROM THE FOLLOWING LIST OF NOMINEES .....

This past Monday and Tuesday, the 3rd DCA JNC interviewed a total of 17 for two open seats on the appellate court.  Today, the JNC narrowed the list to ten and forwarded those names to Governor Scott for his consideration.  The list includes six current and one former judge among the ten nominees.

Governor Scott has 60 days to name replacements for Judges Leslie Rothenberg and Richard Suarez. The two new judges will likely be chosen just two weeks before Scott leaves office as a lame duck Governor.

The list of nominees (click on the names of the last three listed below to be taken to their complete bio):

Hon. Monica Gordo
- 19 years Florida Bar; Circuit Court Family Division; eight years on the bench; former ASA

Hon. Eric Hendon
- 39 years Florida Bar; Circuit Court Criminal Division;  sixteen years on the bench; former ASA, APD, AAG

Hon. Timothy Koenig
- 34 years Florida Bar; Circuit Court Monroe County; four years on the bench; thirty years in private practice

Hon. Fleur Lobree
- 26 years Florida Bar; former Circuit Court judge (2 years) and County Court judge (1 year); former AAG, ASA

Hon. Bronwyn Miller
- 21 years Florida Bar; Circuit Court Civil Division; thirteen years on the bench; former ASA

Hon. Thomas Rebull
- 21 years Florida Bar; Circuit Court Civil Division; seven years on the bench; fourteen years in private practice

Hon. Lisa Walsh
- 26 years Florida Bar; Circuit Court Criminal Division; ten years on the bench; former APD

Oren Rosenthal 
-22 years Florida Bar; currently an Assistant Miami-Dade County Attorney; Oren Rosenthal currently serves as the lead attorney for the Miami-Dade Elections Department and the Information Technology Department. Oren has previously served as a member of the Federal Litigation section of the office. Oren is experienced as a litigator and as a transactional lawyer. Oren's litigation experience includes federal civil rights suits, intellectual property claims, complex commercial matters, as well as challenges to elections and the Miami-Dade County Home Rule Charter. Oren has also handled numerous appeals before both state and federal appellate courts.

Ann St. Peter-Griffith
-24 years Florida Bar; currently with Kasowitz, Benson, Torres LLP; has a national practice that focuses on all aspects of complex commercial litigation, including health care, Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, False Claims Act, product liability, constitutional, and employment discrimination cases in federal and state trial and appellate courts. Also represents health care clients in civil and criminal matters throughout the United States. Former AUSA. 

Melissa Damian Visconti
-23 years Florida Bar; currently Of Counsel to Damian & Valori; experienced trial and appellate lawyer who has appeared in state and federal courts across Florida and around the country. Ms. Visconti is Of Counsel to the Firm and focuses her practice in the areas of state and federal court appeals, complex litigation, and receiverships. Ms. Visconti has extensive experience in state and federal appeals courts, as well as in the areas of products liability, whistleblower and False Claims Act cases, securities, multidistrict litigation, and class action litigation. She is also experienced in criminal law, advising clients who are the subjects of or material witnesses in federal and state investigations

Who didn’t make the final cut:

Hon. Jason Bloch
Hon. Alexander Bokor
Hon. George Sarduy
Hon. Angelica Zayas
Jeffrey Geldens
Kansas Gooden
Edward Guedes

Predictions anyone?

CAPTAIN OUT .......
Captain4Justice@gmail.com


18 comments:

Anonymous said...

I am an advocate and a long time admirer of Judge Lisa Walsh. First class. Let’s help her with the Governor.

Anonymous said...

Surprised Zayas didn't make the cut.

Anonymous said...

A lot of great talent in that list..........

BTDT

Anonymous said...

I don't know if I want someone named "Peter Griffith" on the 3d DCA--might start an apocalyptic fight with a giant chicken and destroy the courthouse.

Ivy Ginsberg said...

Ann St. Peter-Griffiths and one of the Circuit Court Judges.

Anonymous said...

Captain. Please explain how Scott gets to name the replacements. Isn’t this the same case as the Florida Supreme Court and the three retiring justices. Aren’t Rothenberg and Suarez leaving right at end of Scott’s term. This makes no sense and it’s bullshit. Where’s Mitch McConnell when you need him.

Hope that Lisa Walsh gets named. She is so qualified and deserving.

Thanks for your updates.

Anonymous said...

Gordo would be so over her head its not funny. She would be the same as the retiring Rottenberg. Bad for Plaintiffs and criminal defendants. I am surprised she made the last list. Very sad.

Anonymous said...

It is total bullshit. Why didn’t the League of Women Voters file suit against Rick Scott on this crap. How does he get to name the replacements. He leaves office same day the two judges do. Someone call LWV and tell them to file.

CAPTAIN JUSTICE said...


CESAR SAYOC .....

I just heard CBS NEWS quoting attorney "Ronald Lowy" stating that Lowy represented Sayoc in the past and providing the news with several observations about his client's state of mind.

Lowy did in fact represent Sayoc in F02-24800, Bomb Threat charge, Probation.

Why is Lowy speaking with the press about his perceptions of his client's state of mind from 16 years ago?

I noticed that Dan Lurvey also represented the man in 2013 on a Petit Theft charge. Have they called you too Dan?

Cap Out .....


Anonymous said...

Scott Saul represented him in the past too.

Anonymous said...

Lisa Walsh would be great, but Scott will pick Hendon and Koenig.

Anonymous said...

Can we label Sayok a deplorable?

Anonymous said...

Who is the biggest Republican donor? Who does the Federalist Society want? Those will be your picks. Scott is crow-barring these picks in.

You make it sound like the resume matters.

Anonymous said...

642 we can definately label you a world class moron

Anonymous said...

2:30: because they resigned early specifically so as to give Scott the right to make the appointment.

Anonymous said...

Whats with these lawyers trashing their former client?

Anonymous said...

My question is, how is a van like that on the road and the owner not being investigated. Nice police work.

the trialmaster said...

Herndon would be awesome on the 3d. He is my choice.