JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG

WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL RICHARD E GERSTEIN JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG. THIS BLOG IS DEDICATED TO JUSTICE BUILDING RUMOR, HUMOR, AND A DISCUSSION ABOUT AND BETWEEN THE JUDGES, LAWYERS AND THE DEDICATED SUPPORT STAFF, CLERKS, COURT REPORTERS, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS WHO LABOR IN THE WORLD OF MIAMI'S CRIMINAL JUSTICE. POST YOUR COMMENTS, OR SEND RUMPOLE A PRIVATE EMAIL AT HOWARDROARK21@GMAIL.COM. Winner of the prestigious Cushing Left Anterior Descending Artery Award.

Tuesday, February 11, 2020

MORENO TO TAKE SENIOR STATUS

DOM broke the news yesterday on his blog. 

Judge Federico Moreno has had a lasting impact on the judiciary and community of South Florida. He made news as a County Court Judge by going home over lunch and bringing a child seat for a woman who appeared in his court for a violation and didn't have the money to buy a safety seat for her child. He issued a traffic bench warrant for a Dolphin wide receiver and then hand wrote "Don't arrest on Sundays." 

He went from county court to circuit court to the federal bench to chief judge of the Southern District and he did it with humility, humor, hard work, and a dedication to serving the people of this community. But for an ill-timed election, he would have spent the majority of his career on the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. 

Their loss is our gain as Judge Moreno spent his career presiding over trials, dispensing justice, and tormenting lawyers with his (in)famous calendar calls which were no less rigorous then a 20 minute oral argument before the US Supreme Court.  If you wanted a continuance he would react as if he was personally wounded.  "This case is (fill in the blank- 6 weeks, six months, one year old!!) ____how did this one slip by me ?" he would wonder out loud. If you mentioned you needed more time to prepare he shot back "You're a great lawyer. This is easy for you. How much time do you need? We can start at 10 am instead of 9 am..." No mater what you answered you were in box until (sometimes) he would dramatically sigh and wonder if he was getting soft in his old age and give you the time you needed. It was a show, and we were all along for the ride.  Do yourself a favor and pop by and watch a calendar call. It's a treat. 

Trials moved crisply. Time wasn't wasted and woe to any lawyer who was seconds late or unprepared. Personally, we never felt safe showing up anything other than an hour early. 

But justice was done. Judge Moreno could separate the wheat from the chafe. He knew a good case from a bad one, and a serious case from one that was a governmental exercise in bureaucracy. 

Judge Moreno was loyal to a fault. Look at the bench and see how many  "Moreno Clerks"  are now Judges. He was a mentor to a generation of young lawyers and Judges. No investiture was complete without an appearance by Judge Moreno with the explanation of how he affected that Judge's career. 

Review all we have written, and one thing becomes clear- This is what a Judge should be. 
Taking senior status means Judge Moreno will still do what he loves. How can he do anything else? He belongs on the bench, inquisitive mind probing the lawyers, finding the weakness in their arguments, making a ruling, wondering our loud if "three judges wiser than me" ( a phrase he appears to have invented- we first saw him use it in State Court) will agree with him.  
Another memory we have is him complaining during his arraignments in state court that "that blind clerk doesn't like me", because we were all told cases were "blind filed" and he felt he was getting a lot of cases. But make no mistake. He watched his numbers closely and was always one of the most efficient and hardest working judges in the court house. 

Judge Moreno was and is a great judge. Sui Generis. And we are lucky he chose to serve our community. 

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

It is a testament to Judge Moreno that Chief Judge Mike Moore never considered taking Judge Moreno’s chambers

Anonymous said...

Humility? Moreno? Are we talking about the same judge? While I agree that he was efficient and could separate wheat from chaff, let's just say that humility was not his strong suit. While I did see him give some very fair sentences, he could also be incredibly cruel. Not to mention that he always believed himself to be the smartest person in the room - sometimes he was. Many times, he wasn't.

Anonymous said...

A bully plain and simple

Anonymous said...

Certainly not the worst. Loved jacking attorneys around on continuances and wasting everyone's time when all knew he would end up granting it. Ultimately he was fair and did not automatically go the way of the Government. Came from a criminal defense firm with Emmas, ( a 3d DCA judge) Thornton( MD Circuit judge recently now a mediator.) and Rothman still a top notch criminal defense attorney. Would rather appear in front of him then any of the others. Still had a rather large ego. I loved overhearing the other judges great him as Chief" Guess that is a black robed deal... I think its stupid. But then again, I never wanted be a judge.

civil guys said...

Rump, only you can settle this raging argument in my office. Halsey at Leyte Gulf, the Japanese tricked him or not?
Settle the issue..."The world wonders" (hint hint)

Anonymous said...

How about treatment modalities for atypical tachycardia? Rumpole disagrees with a local and well known cardiologist.

Rumpole said...

"The world wonders" is a reference to a message from Admiral Halsey that may or may not have been intended to insult Admiral Halsey. Halsey went chasing a fictitious Japanese carrier force and left Leyte undefended. The Japanese took advantage of Halsey's aggressive nature and set a trap. Very simply Halsey fell for the trap. Halsey's message was "where is task force 34 The world wonders". The phrase the world wonders has been dismissed as excess verbiage to trick Japanese codebreaks.
Leyte Gulf was fascinating for military historians like myself because it represents one of last major naval battles where opposing forces were operating with imperfect information about location and size of the other force.

Real Fake Admiral Halsey said...

TURKEY TROTS TO WATER GG FROM CINCPAC ACTION COM THIRD FLEET INFO COMINCH CTF SEVENTY-SEVEN X WHERE IS RPT WHERE IS TASK FORCE THIRTY FOUR RR THE WORLD WONDERS

Anonymous said...

Moreno is no Judge Hanzman.

What does that statement mean to you trial lawyer reader?

Anonymous said...

His words still echo throughout the REGJB...."Jr, bring me a jury NOW..."

Anonymous said...

No judge takes greater delight in belittling lawyers

Anonymous said...

When I was a young lawyer, my senior partners accompanied me to a hearing to make an argument for a client of his. The lawyer on the other side, who was then a partner of a lawyer who had once been with our firm, made a comment about his new partner as being "O.K.," but not always as bright as he thought. My mentor told me that that guy could not kiss the boots of the supposedly "O.K." lawyer.
So, if any of you really think that Judge Moreno, who commands a national reputation, who has more former clerks as state and federal judges than any of his peers, who was known by and invited to almost all presidential inaugurations, and whose sharp wit and intellect are really second to none, is just O.K. or is a drum beater, just keep it to yourself. It only minimizes who you are and makes it clear that having a judge like him handle your case is a waste of superb judicial talent.
Judge Moreno is a short giant of a man, whose performance and stature on the U.S. District Court has made it a better place. May he grace the Court for years to come, and may I be privileges to practice before him as often as I can!

Anonymous said...

I hope you proof read your writing better than the slop you posted here, when you are before Judge Moreno.

Anonymous said...

Sorry; Wrote it on a phone. Actually, when I appear before him and speak, he doesn't see any misspellings.