JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG

WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL RICHARD E GERSTEIN JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG. THIS BLOG IS DEDICATED TO JUSTICE BUILDING RUMOR, HUMOR, AND A DISCUSSION ABOUT AND BETWEEN THE JUDGES, LAWYERS AND THE DEDICATED SUPPORT STAFF, CLERKS, COURT REPORTERS, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS WHO LABOR IN THE WORLD OF MIAMI'S CRIMINAL JUSTICE. POST YOUR COMMENTS, OR SEND RUMPOLE A PRIVATE EMAIL AT HOWARDROARK21@GMAIL.COM. Winner of the prestigious Cushing Left Anterior Descending Artery Award.

Sunday, July 21, 2024

THIS MOMENT IN TIME

 “There are decades when nothing happened and weeks when decades happen” Lenin was reportedly to have said. 

Now are those weeks when decades are happening. 

An older person, with decades of admirable service to community is seeing all they built crumble around them. They appear frozen in the headlights, unable to respond as they did in their younger days- when confidence and talent carried the day. 

And then there is Joe Biden. 

But first our State Attorney. 

When did she surround herself with sycophants, all assuring her that her top prosecutor who goes by the initials MVZ knew what he was doing? When did the hallmark of honesty and integrity become replaced by a win at all costs attitude? For decades prosecutors had to deal with cops who stretched the line of truth because they “knew” the defendant was guilty and did not trust the system. Then, slowly, Miami Prosecutors (at least some of them) adopted the same philosophy. And now, faced with the biggest scandal in the history of the once proud Miami State Attorneys Office, our State Attorney stubbornly and steadfastly refuses to allow outside oversight over their convictions - not even the ones obtained by MVZ who has been proven to be a liar, and possibly worse. (There is a name for turning a blind eye to illicit drug use and sexual assignations). Where is the criminal investigation for obstruction of justice? The SAO is investigating two assistant PDs for possibly telling a witness to not appear. But they do nothing when MVZ coordinates the testimony of jailhouse snitches and then lies about it? Really?? 

Speaking of stubborn, as KFR says everything is ok, so does her aging counterpart at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. Also surrounded by sycophants, his staff gaslighted the news media and the Democratic Party a year ago as rumors of his age, illness and infirmity began to circulate. And what have they wrought? Nothing other than handing over the White House to a convicted felon and party bent on destroying American ideals, unless your view of American ideals is isolationism,  xenophobia, and a cult of personality. 

We will be held accountable  in both Miami and by the world,  if we standby while the concepts of justice and America are torn apart. 

Maybe a few judges and ASAs should read what happened to James Joseph Richardson - wrongfully convicted of the murder of his seven children and sentenced to death. He was exonerated and rereleased after a State Attorney and her staff proved his innocence. 

That State Attorney? Janet Reno and the Miami Dade State Attorneys Office (with the investigation led by Asa Don Horn) back when justice was their highest calling- not coordinating the statements of jail house snitches. 

In Europe world leaders fret and make plans for the next Trump Administration, with a vice president who wants to abandon Ukraine who is fighting Russia alone as England fought Hitler alone in 1939-1942.  

It takes a lifetime to build a reputation. And it can be lost in a minute by the actions of MVZ or DT. 

Churchill and Roosevelt and Eisenhower were men who met the moment. Janet Reno was the woman who time and time again told her prosecutors to go where the evidence led them- winning was at the bottom of the list. Justice was at the top. 

Where are these people when we need them now? 


(Ps we wrote this early Sunday before the Biden announcement but decided to run it anyway. You get the point. Well, we shouldn’t assume that should we? Some of you get the point.  The rest are busy reading MAGA crap about Harris not being eligible to be president or Hillary using Hunter’s laptop to trick the media into not reporting how ill Biden was. Speaking of old age - whose age is an issue for the presidency now? Lmfao ). 

44 comments:

Anonymous said...

https://www.google.com/search?q=your+time+is+gonna+come.&client=safari&sca_esv=d4fe766562f09bfd&sca_upv=1&hl=en-us&sxsrf=ADLYWIIzKOSaA5Mg1ApGn92zypU1nXacVw%3A1721601374754&ei=Xo2dZurSLfnKp84Px6mWiAk&oq=your+time+is+gonna+come.&gs_lp=EhNtb2JpbGUtZ3dzLXdpei1zZXJwIhh5b3VyIHRpbWUgaXMgZ29ubmEgY29tZS4yChAAGLADGNYEGEcyChAAGLADGNYEGEcyChAAGLADGNYEGEcyChAAGLADGNYEGEcyChAAGLADGNYEGEcyChAAGLADGNYEGEcyChAAGLADGNYEGEcyChAAGLADGNYEGEdIjwdQAFgAcAN4AZABAJgBAKABAKoBALgBA8gBAJgCA6ACCpgDAIgGAZAGCJIHATOgBwA&sclient=mobile-gws-wiz-serp

Anonymous said...

The Assistant State Attorney who worked with Janet Reno to exonerate James Richardson for poisionin to death his 7 children was Don L. Horn. Every year he lectured the new prosecutors on “Justice Above All” where he details the crazy journey of that exoneration and others.

Anonymous said...

Great post

Anonymous said...

Can someone explain what is going on here. It’s all a bit confusing

Anonymous said...

Humility is not a trait that many have in that office.

Anonymous said...

The ASA did a terrible argument last week responding to this motion. The courtroom was packed. Judge face said it all

Anonymous said...

Insanity

Anonymous said...

Holy Sycophants!!

Anonymous said...

The defense bar comparing Rundle to Biden = priceless.

Anonymous said...

You are amazing. Up until the last few days, we heard nothing about Joe Biden's lousy performance. Now, you take a shot at him along with Kathy.
The fact is that Kathy is too loyal to people. She is not dishonest, but she is a public official, and when the public loses faith in your office, you have to clean house. That is what she needs to do.
How about the practice when you lose a CCF or convicted firearm carry, you ship the defendant to the feds. MVZ was no prize. All he wanted to do was win and to demonstrate that even though he could only function as an ASA where you can control the cards, he was still a world class lawyer. What he was and is is a crook and an unethical practitioner. It took someone with balls like Judge Wolfson to call him down even when the defendant was not a prince. And, Judge Wolfson was willing to put a Third DCA judge on the stand who was really upset, but that was the right thing to do.
All of us suffer if the State Attorney's office is not up to snuff. All of us suffer when the PD's office is overworked and understaffed. All of us suffer hen we allow colleagues that we know do not give a crap about their clients, but only their retainers. Line your pockets, take a plea. They are probably guilty anyway. All of us are responsible for that too.
As for foreign policy, I am far more concerned about Israel than I am the Ukraine because I know the government of Israel is honest an that Israel is the cradle of so many of our faiths. Whether you like Trump or not, when he was president there were no new wars, NATO partners were paying their fair share, he economy was good for everyone, not just Wall Street, and we were promoting and recruiting talent based on ability as opposed to which letter of the alphabet someone represents.
Kathy has some problems, but she has been a good and honest public servant. Those of us who have worked for her need to remind her that she has the ability and the power to emulate Janet and make the State Attorney's Office great again.

Anonymous said...

Patience, Rumpy. A big announcement is coming.

Anonymous said...

Best written piece on our times yet. Only you could link Lenin KFR Biden and the exoneration of James Richardson. I bet a bunch of DeSantis drones are saying to themselves “I always wondered which case created a Richardson hearing “ lol. For you drones it wasn’t this Richardson. It was an earlier one.

Big fan Rumph. Would love to meet you for a drink some night if you would date your readers. 😈

Inner circle said...

You don’t know this rump but KFR is screaming reading this. No one and I mean no one is allowed to mention Janet in front of her.

Anonymous said...

Next move - we are going to see Handfield, Fingerhut or some other loyal defense puppet named a “Rundle” consultant/staffer. He will come in once every two/three months, sit in meetings, not review a case file and get paid what Mary Cagle gets paid or more to be Rundle’s “employee apartment rental consultant” because Bowman was too lazy to do that as part of his recruitment and retention job and because a favor needed to happen. Every couple of months Cagle sends an email office wide with apartment rental information. Would be interested to see how many hours a week she is logging at 175$ an hour to research rental properties for staff. If the public knew the waste and mismanagement happening in that office they would vomit.

Anonymous said...

Kathy is not loyal to anyone but herself. She has always been known to shit talk everyone on her leadership team and pit them against each other. That is the joke of the office and the way she keeps everyone under control and on edge. She has been doing this for decades. And to say she is not dishonest is a farce and everyone knows it. Nice try at damage control but it’s the worst kept dirty little secret.

SAO OFFICE CONTROL said...

Folks this is serious. It’s not going away. We need to redirect the attention of judges and the media. There is too much focus on our prosecutors getting caught on chess game discovery issues. We’ve gotten away with this for decades. Let’s find a judge who doesn’t give the max after a trial and go on the offensive. Let’s find some aggressive PDs and charge them.
In Summary let’s charge the narrative away from us. Your jobs depend on it.

SAO control out.


The script for the Monday morning call text from SAO control to the Asa drones.

Anonymous said...

A fake announcement is coming

Anonymous said...

Nailed it!!

Anonymous said...

They are afraid of Handfield.

Anonymous said...

Can someone share the order Wolfson wrote on the other ASA and discovery violations or at least share a name and case number?

Anonymous said...

That was abahof

Anonymous said...

“Judge Wolfson again found an ASA to have violated discovery rules multiple times. There is a written opinion. Someone needs to refer it to the bar. She is incompetent and arrogant. Let the bar say what she did was ok or not. Until these prosecutors feel the effects of doing this there will be no change. Part of feeling the effects is having to respond to a bar complaint about your conduct. This arrogance has to stop. There is a momentum and it should continue as things are daily revealed and uncovered.” Who is the ASA?

Anonymous said...

Israel is honest? Ha. They kill dozens of innocent people to take a crack at 1 terrorist. Then say, we will conduct an internal review. We will never hear anything about it again. They have a bunch of internal reviews going on right now because they have killed almost 40,000 people, a huge amount of which are women and children. What a great and honest country. Their prime minister is holding onto power so he doesn’t go to jail for bribery. Honest. They expanded settlements more during the last 10 months than in the previous 49 years. These settlements are illegal and an international court just confirmed that fact. Honest. Stealing land in the name of peace, murdering civilians in the name of security, undermining international organizations such as the UN and ICC. Honest. Now (again) coming before our congress to interfere with our internal politics. Honest. What a load of crap it is for me, a Jew, to see people call the Israeli government honest and decent.

Anonymous said...

I’m assuming that integrity czar Gosney wasn’t able to yet train, or he wasn’t consulted by, this other ASA. Hopefully the creepy factor isn’t an integrity repeller.

Anonymous said...

No Goz sightings!

Anonymous said...

What a disaster for the Democratic Party. Kamala Harris is not talented. Once the polls reflect that she has zero chance the problems will start. The convention could be a shit show.

Anonymous said...

Can someone share Wolfson courtroom number. And is this on at 9?

Anonymous said...

Kamala with the women of this country behind her are going to take down that dirty old man. "These Girls Are On Fire" !!!

Anonymous said...

Sounds like wishful thinking 9:32. I look forward to Kamala the prosecutor taking down your "talented" criminal.

Anonymous said...

Spot on 9:07 a.m. I, too am Jewish and I think that Netanyahu is a dishonest fraud using the war for his own personal gain. He should be the cell mate to the American convicted felon also trying in any way to keep himself out of prison. Maybe one day Israel will once again be a country I can be proud of and look at as my homeland. Today is not that day.

Anonymous said...

THE MIAMI STATE ATTORNEYS OFFICE PULLING THIS UNETHICAL BEHAVIOR TOWARDS OUR FELLOW APDS WHO DID NOTHING MORE THAN INVESTIGATE - SOMETHING THEIR OATH REQUIRES - AND NOW JUDGE CRAZY CARMEN CABARGA JUST SIGNED 30 RECUSAL ORDERS AT ONCE TO REMOVE A YOUNG PD FROM HER COURTROOM - AND WE ARE FINDING OUT IT'S THE SAME APD SHE THREATENED TO HOLD IN CONTEMPT IN THE TRIAL A FEW MONTHS AGO. THE ENTIRE SYSTEM IS FALLING APART. HOPEFULLY THESE RECUSED CASES END UP BEFORE A JUDGE WITH SOME LOGIC AND THE PROPER TEMPERMENT TO BE ON THE BENCH UNLIKE A BIG BABY WHO IS EITHER YELLING, CRYING, OR RECUSING ON THE BENCH. THEY ALL MUST GO!

Anonymous said...

Cabarga does not have the temperament to be a judge. When is her term up?

Anonymous said...

The apd to whom you refer is known to have problems with her cases and clients. If you talk to any supervisor off the record at the pd's office they will tell you the truth- there are people in jail that should not be there because of her poor performance. She has personality issues that distract her from her cases and make her ineffective at her job and innocent people are sitting in jail.

Anonymous said...

Leonard Thompson Jr

Anonymous said...

Is this the apd who judge cabarga kicked out of the courtroom today resulting in judge cabarga being removed from the courtroom effective monday morning???? jw

Anonymous said...

So, why is the PDO not doing something about this? Why are colleagues in the courtroom not making PDO aware of this? And why isn’t the judge letting the PDO know by forwarding the orders to her supervisor?

Anonymous said...

Blog moderator: you allow people to post the name of ASA's along with negative comments but you don't allow any comment about this APD to be posted when her name is disclosed?

Anonymous said...

Judge Cabarga “removed from the courtroom effective Monday morning?” What do you mean? 🤔

Anonymous said...

The PDO did something about this. Judge C no longer runs division 1.

Anonymous said...

🤔

Anonymous said...

I wish someone would take a deep dive of all of the ASAs (and judges) who have dated cops over the years. Then take a closer look at all of these same ASAs who have listed random cops as "essential" witnesses just so these guys could get paid.

Anonymous said...

Rump.....why are you allowing this? The order had nothing to do with Thompson (which should have been obvious to you, as the first writer indicated, it dealt with a female ASA). Allowing the personal attacks and ridicule is bad enough.....please abide by your policy of not allowing unsubstantiated - let alone false - accusations.

Rumpole said...

Can you please point me to the comment you want removed ? Date and time and I will review. Thanks.

Anonymous said...

That case is in trial now in 4-1 before Wolfson. Abahoff is a joke. Defense team killing it. All of the witnesses have been impeached for changing their testimony days before the trial, 4 years after the incident. Every re-direct is Abahoff trying to convince the jury he didn’t tamper with the witness. I thoroughly believe any allegations of tampering the defense has lodged against abahoff on this case. It’s pathetic. “Win at all costs!”