JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG

WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL RICHARD E GERSTEIN JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG. THIS BLOG IS DEDICATED TO JUSTICE BUILDING RUMOR, HUMOR, AND A DISCUSSION ABOUT AND BETWEEN THE JUDGES, LAWYERS AND THE DEDICATED SUPPORT STAFF, CLERKS, COURT REPORTERS, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS WHO LABOR IN THE WORLD OF MIAMI'S CRIMINAL JUSTICE. POST YOUR COMMENTS, OR SEND RUMPOLE A PRIVATE EMAIL AT HOWARDROARK21@GMAIL.COM. Winner of the prestigious Cushing Left Anterior Descending Artery Award.

Monday, March 13, 2006

LOCKEM UP SAM SLOM WRITES A BILL???

HB 409 - Driving Under the Influence

GENERAL BILL by Rep. Planas
Driving Under the Influence: Requires that a defendant charged with driving under the influence be held in custody until a first appearance hearing; requires specified investigation prior to and presentation of findings at such a hearing; specifies factors to be considered in determining whether to grant pretrial release; prohibits release of a defendant after a first appearance hearing until specified conditions are met.
Effective Date: July 1, 2006.

Last Event: Withdrawn prior to introduction on Thursday, January 05, 2006 1:39 PM


Representative JC Planas proposed the above bill to the Florida Legislature (The Tallahassee Lassies, or lap-dogs, which ever you prefer.)

Get the full text here of Plana’s pandering for MADD votes, by searching “bills” and then “Planas”.
http://www.myfloridahouse.gov/

What you won’t find while searching for the full text of the bill are the hands behind this MADD bill. Not surprisingly you will find the Dade State Attorneys Office, and their County Court Chief.

Surprisingly however (although many say they are not surprised) , people are making serious allegations that you will also find the hands of Chief County Court Criminal Divison Judge Sam “lock em up” Slom.

If and only if this allegation is true: and that is a big IF (we are giving the Judge the benefit of the doubt here) then....


What in the name of John Ashscroft is a sitting Judge doing conspiring, combining and confederating with The State Attorneys Office to get a bill passed that will make it more difficult for people arrested for DUI to bond out?

If Judge Slom did not help write the bill and work with the State to get it introduced, then he has nothing to answer for. However, if he did help the State lobby for the bill, then we think he has a lot to answer for.


Lets play pretend: Pretend the bill passed, and we will fast forward to a Saturday bond hearing sometime next year.

A young woman and her 7 year old son sit with their attorney in the bond hearing courtroom on the 5th Floor. Her husband was arrested Thursday night by Officer Closius after he left his second job as a bartender. Closius wrote in the report that he noticed the strong odor of alcoholic beverages on the Defendant. Closius ignored the Defendant’s explanation that he weaved a little because he works two jobs and only sleeps 5 hours night.

The woman is worried because the man was fired from his Janitors job for not showing up for work Friday, and she is not sure how she is going to pay the attorney, post bond, and make rent next month.

The bailiff walks in and says “all rise” and in strolls Judge Slom.

The attorney frowns.
The woman whispers :”do you know this Judge?”
The attorney sadly nods. “Yes, he was the person who along the prosecutor’s office wrote the new DUI law that prevented your Husband from being released from Jail yesterday.”

Astonished, the woman asks, her voice rising above a whisper: “How is he going to be fair? He’s the one who wrote the law making it more difficult for people like my husband to bond out?”


”I’m afraid so" says the attorney. "And MADD gave him an award a few months ago to boot.”

Florida Judicial Cannons of Ethics:

CANNON 2: A Judge Shall Avoid Impropriety, and the Appearance of Impropriety
in all of the Judge's Activities.


Lets look at this another way. Governor Bush falls off his dirt bike while riding with his brother and hits his head. In a daze, he appoints Richard Hersch to the County Court. (For this scenario, the cheap shot is against the Governor. He would never appoint anyone so qualified and reasonable and experienced. We know Mr. Hersch would make a great judge.)

And lets say, Judge Hersch, following Judge Slom’s example, meets with Bennett Brummer and the President of the FACDL and they draft legislation amending the DUI law to remove the presumption of impairment for people driving with a Blood Alcohol level above a .08.

“Presumptions against criminal defendants are unconstitutional” writes Judge Hersch. Hersch and company find a sympathetic legislator, and the bill is submitted.

The following Monday the State Attorneys Office storms to Judge Slom, who happens to be having coffee in their office anyway, and demands Judge Hersch be removed from the criminal bench.

“How can we have confidence that the State will get a fair trial before Judge Hersch when he is lobbying against the laws we enforce?” they whine.

The point is that Judges can engage in activity "to improve the law, the legal system and the administration of justice." So says Cannon 4 of the Cannon’s of Judicial Ethics.

But Cannon 2 requires the Judge to avoid even the appearance of impropriety.

IF- and this is a BIG IF: Judge Lock em up Slom worked with the prosecution to write and/or promote the new proposed bill, then his activities give the appearance of bias against people arrested for DUI. We would be hard pressed to find any way Judge Slom could continue to sit in criminal court while working for enactment of stricter DUI laws. In fact, just working with the State Attorneys Office (or the PD's Office) on any proposed bill would give any Judge the appearance of impropriety.

Some may say that there is a flaw in the system that allows certain Defendants to bond out prior to a court hearing. That is not a Judge's concern. A Judge's job is to apply the law as written.

Isn't this what conservatives whine about all the time? Activist Judges? Don't the conservatives sing and dance that it is up to citizens to work with the legislature to enact new laws, and for Judges to merely interpret those laws? Or is it OK for a Judge to be an activist as long as s/he is an activist for the "right" (right wing) causes?


We think that there may be another more sinister side to this.

If Judge Slom has created an appearance of impropriety regarding DUI bonds, then he should never sit on a bond hearing calendar again.

Ever.

And what an ingenious way for a Judge to avoid that Sunday New Years Day Bond Duty!!!! Judge Slom may just be a genius!!! (At least we give credit where it is due.)

Seriously, it would be nice if Judge Slom could respond to this. This blog has published this post based on reports from several disgruntled attorneys. So at the very least, Judge Slom should know he is the subject of a troubling allegation.

We are not sure what, if anything Judge Slom actually did. But other attorneys think Judge Slom has been actively working for a new strict DUI law.

We are willing to give Judge Slom the benefit of presuming him innocent of any wrongdoing until it is proven otherwise.

Which is more than a person arrested for DUI would get under the proposed legislation.

See You In Court.




Sunday, March 12, 2006

TALLAHASSEE LASSIES

Jason Grey checks in with Tallahassee news:

The legislature is trying to make it a 1st degree MM to refuse to blow even once. It would be nice to know that the intoxilyzer actually works as advertised. When my computer starts acting up and spits out crap I do what everyone else does, unplug it and it "fixes" itself.That's why monthly maintence checks are bullshit. Just cause it worked ok one day last month and again yesterday doesnt mean it worked ok in between.I don't see the metro dade crime lab using cops to maintain their equiptment.

And in the comments section, breaking news that the State Attorney's other son was arrested for tresspass over the weekend. This cannot be easy for the State Attorney. Unfortunately for her family, she is a public figure, so what they do makes the news.

OK. We are soliciting some help here. We have some credible information that one County Court Judge has been burning the midnight oil working with the State Attorneys Office to create a bill making it harder for people arrested for DUI to bond out. We know the name of the Judge. We know the bill. Before we publish our no holds barred condemnation of this Judge, we want to confirm just exactly what he did. Any help here?

MULDOWNY UPDATE

Team Muldowny Attorney Richard Hersch sends in this report:


I can report on Muldowny (in this forum) by saying that the evidence came in as well or better than expected. A full and comprehensive examination of the science, the inherent weaknesses and lack of forensic precision of breath testing, the computer driven nature of the Intoxilyzer, the importance of the software, the multitude of reasons why the software validly should be examined, the lack of legitimacy of a "trade secret" objection, and other issues was had. The judges had the benefit of testimony from the finest experts in the country on these issues. To everyone who has joined in, helped financially with the astronomical costs associated with expedited depositions, use of experts, etc., and otherwise assisted, many thanks. More work is yet to be done, but the last two days have provided a very good evidentiary base upon which the judges can reach their conclusions.

Big thanks to Mike and Maggie, they were great.
Oh, and to anonymous out there, when was the last time you fielded this type of case in your felony practice?



Anonymous sends in this report:

(Limited) Report From The Muldowny Front:The defendant's expert witness, a Ph.D in electrical engineering (and also an M.D.) was very impressive in his explanation as to what is going on inside the machines, the changes made by the police to the original machines, and why the source code needs to be reviewed to help explain these changes. It was dry but interesting at the same time.My question: Why is administrative chief Judge Sam Slom sitting in on the hearings? He doesn't hear any cases anymore; is it so he can try to influence the other judges to deny the defense motions?



And Anonymous has come to praise Richard Hersch not bury him:

Richard Hersch did a masterful job of getting the CMI expert to admit that there is no commercial value to the source code and that CMI would not lose anything financially or competitively by divulging same. He had their witness agreeing to discuss divulging the source code with CMI's board of directors!! Great job Muldowny team!


While this reader wants to do the reverse:

LOL. We're very impressed Richard. You found experts who will say what you want in exchange for lucrative careers as "expert witnesses" in DUI cases. Yawn. And, no, that crap would never fly in front of most circuit judges.


And this reader comments on our local fishwrap:

Judges sitting in a jury box, while they aren't a jury, they sure look like one.And while 600 defendants aren't represented by 3 attorneys, they sure look like they are.Misreporting or not, sensationalism sells - the plain truth seldom does.


Anonymous wrote in about Judge Hendon's new appointment:

hendon has an iq of about 100.

Rumpole responds: Judge Hendon will not make friends with the other Judges if he brags about his superior intelligence and IQ (vis a vis his brethern on the bench.)

Rumpole concludes: Richard Hersch's full post, in the comments sections shows that he is not only a master of DUI complexities, but a historian of WWII naval battles. A true renaissance man. Why is Judge Slom sitting in on these motions, but other judges that handle a DUI calendar are notably absent? More on Judge Slom's DUI hijinks coming up soon.




Friday, March 10, 2006

WILL THE HERALD EVER LEARN???

Is it too much to ask for Miami’s only daily newspaper to properly and correctly cover the legal community in Miami? Or should we indulge the Herald in its stupid mistakes, because they make good headlines?

Case in point, the local coverage of the Muldowny Hearings.

The blurb on the bottom of the front page of today's local section states" Judges Act As Jury In DUI Case."


Lets play our current favorite game of count the errors.
1) The Judges aren't acting as jury (as the article on page 3 admits).
2) Its not a DUI case. Its a consolidated motion convering more than 600 defendants.

But why let a little thing like the truth stand between a good headline?

Now, is the Herald really that stupid to believe that all the county court judges will be the jury for a DUI case? Of course not. But rather than report the truth, the Herald resorts to an eye catching headline that panders to public misperception of the legal system.

The article on the Muldowny hearings written by Natalie McNeal correctly states that the Judges are all sitting together to listen to the evidence and that each Judge is free to issue their own separate rulings. So if the Herald knows that, why print a patently false headline?

However, Ms. McNeal is not totally off the hook. The article states "Represented by three defense attorneys- two private and one public defender- are at least 600 defendants charged with DUI in Miami."


WRONG. WRONG WRONG.

Querry: is the reporter that clueless or just unable to properly explain the actual scenario?

As we all know, the attorneys for the 600 DUI defendants all agreed to have the three lawyers handle the motions for the entire group of defendants.


Is that so hard to write?
Why mislead the public into believing three lawyers have 600 clients when nothing could be further from the truth? Of course, why mislead the public into believing Judges are acting as a Jury in a DUI prosecution?

Where is our favorite local scribe Oh Susannah when we need her?



As to the Muldowny Hearings, not one word. Not one brave soul has volunteered to act as our eyes and ears on the scene.

“Where is Task Force Muldowny? The World Awaits.”

(Anyone catch the allusion to Admiral Nimitz’s famous wire to Admiral Halsey in the Battle of Leyte Gulf? “Where is Task Force 38? The World Awaits.”


Students of military tactics know that in the naval battle for Leyte Gulf, the Japanese, knowing about US Admiral "Bull” Halsey’s temperament, created through radio traffic a fake naval force, and falsely conveyed to Halsey the idea he could trap the Japanese. The ploy worked to an extent, drawing Halsey and his Naval Forces away from Leyte Gulf and his assignment to guard the San Bernadino Straits. With the Straits unguarded, Japanese Admiral Kurita's Naval force moved through undetected, threatening and attacking US Admiral Sprague's "baby carriers."
These are the times we fondly think about Judge Manny Crespo.)


See You In Court, reading the Sun Sentinel.

Thursday, March 09, 2006

HENDON II

What do Richard Nixon, Alfonso Sepe, Joe Farina and Eric Hendon all have in common? They are political phoenixes rising from the ashes of defeat or (in Farina’s case) resignation.

Congratulations to Eric Hendon, just re-appointed by Governor Bush to a seat on County Court. Welcome back. See You In Court.

Anyone want to give us a Muldowny update? Source Code shenanigans?

Anonymous wrote in with this historic DUI battle:


"Towering genius distains a beaten path. It seeks regions hitherto unexplored."--From the January 27, 1838 Request for Source Code, Abraham Lincoln


Rumpole can’t help showing off superior knowledge of County Court History:

Anonymous wrote:

Re the comments about it being silly to rule that the source code must be turned over: Hey, its county court, what do you want?? I remember when Judge Winton and that mean judge who would sit in temporarily and wear the cobalt blue robe (can't remember his name) made the ASA bring in the photographer to get a photo into evidence.

And Rumpole responds: Why dear reader, you are talking about the one and only Alfred Nesbitt. A cantankerous, ASA hatin, motion to suppress grantin, royal pain in the rear, old school Judge.

See You In Court.

Wednesday, March 08, 2006

MULDOWNY MENU

Muldowny Team Member Michael Catalano writes in with a preview of tomorrows fireworks. For obvious reasons we cannot say whether we will be in attendance and invite Catalano to post a wrap-up of the days events.



To All Defense Attorneys and the Phantom Blogger

From Mike Catalano

This is my unofficial attempt to explain what we are doing with a little bit of comedy thrown in....very little comedy...

Re: Muldowny

The hearings start at 1:30 pm on Thursday March 9th, Courtroom 4-1, MJB.

The first half hour will be wasted with speeches and nothing important.

Then, brief, hopefully very brief opening statements. Yea.... right.

First witness: Stephan Rose, MD. He will explain everything you really need to know about the intoxilzier. He will bring a machine for all to see.

Friday:
We start with Dr. Mylar, the electrical engineer. He will explain that you really can not know what is going on in that box unless you have all the programs... like the source code.

We rest.


State calls Laura Barfield. She is the FDLE boss. She will say, worry not... it works fine and we know it does because we take the word of the manufacturer and have no reason to ask any questions...

State then calls Mr. Schofield. He is the engineering boss at CMI, Inc..... the manufacturer of the machine. He will claim that the machine is fine and we should just take their word for it and he will claim that the 1983 microwave oven technology source code is a trade secret.

Last, they will call Chip Walls to rebut what Rose said. Funny, how a guy with a BS will try to rebut a MD when Walls does not even know what model intoxilizer we use in Dade County.

Most likely, there will be a future hearing date... in a week or so, when all judges will get together and hear final argument.

We hope to have this all wrapped up in two weeks


Rumpole replies: We are sure Richard Hersch will throw an elbow or two during cross and manage to link the fact the government was sure there were WMD's in Iraq with the current prosecution's position that if the FDLE says the machine is OK, then it must be OK.

Querry: why can't the machine be reverse engineered?

Housekeeping: a person posted on the blog using the name of a Judge. But the email address was anonymous. When a Judge makes a a post, it usually comes from their email with an 11th circuit attachment. Any email from anonymous with a Judge's name on it should be treated as phony.

Anonymous wrote:

I heard the PD's office hasn't told their attorneys about the arrest of the cop on perjury charges. Since they're barred from this blog, how will they defend their clients in cases where Gary is the eyeball? Guess the matter of lying cops doesn't bother the office too much.

Rumpole replies: we thought the issue of PD's access to the blog was settled. It is the SAO employees that don't have access to the web. The PD's do.


We leave with a few choice quotes from the Bard for our friends who do battle on the morrow:

One draught above heat makes him a fool; the second mads him; and a third drowns him.

12th Night.

"Things won are done; joy's soul lies in the doing."

A favorite quote of the Bard, but the title of the story escapes us at the moment.
Good Luck tomorrow Team Muldowny.

See You in Court.





TALLAHASSEE PINKS


Rick Freedman writes with important and serious news about Tallahassee and our wonderful legislators:

Rump:

Brian T. points out an important bill in SB 360 that could have a very detrimental effect on all Court Appointed Counsel (CAC) attorneys down the road. There is language in the bill that declares that "the Legislature further finds that not all capital collateral cases are extraordinary or unusual." This language in a frontal attack on the Makemson case. It could eventually trickle down to all cases.

With the opening of the Legislative Session that took place yesterday in Tallahassee, there are other important bills filed that need the attention of all criminal defense lawyers.

In SB 232 (HB187), the bill attempts to make a first refusal in a DUI case a misdemeanor (instead of the second refusal as is now the case). The bill also has language that effectively eliminates all Discovery of Muldowny type material, by specifically limiting what the State is required to make available to the defense during the discovery of the case. If passed, the State would not be required to turn over "manuals, schematics, or software of the instrument used to test the person or any other material that is not in the actual possession of the state. Additionally, full information (what is required to be turned over) does not include information in the possession of the manufacturer of the test instrument."

In SB 538 (HB627), the bill would require all those under a DUI penalty to have a DUI PINK license plate. It would also permit any law enforcement officer the right to stop the vehicle without any probable cause.

There are other bills of importance that you can read online. I am sure that Brian and FACDL will do their best to educate the House and Senate leaders and hopefully to quash some of the more ridiculous parts of some of these bills.

Good luck.


Rumpole notes that Brian T emailed us last night, and notes that he has spent the last two days arguing criminal law with legislators who have never been in a courtroom.


Hmm.. Brian….is that like spending time talking about war with a Vice President who had six deferments?
Or is it like talking about war with a President who went AWOL from the National Guard?
Or is it more like chatting about evidence with a judge who never tried a case as an attorney?

Here is the lesson life teaches us: the people who make the decisions are rarely the ones best qualified to do so.

Further proof God has a sense of humor.
Keep slugging away in Tallahassee, the truth of the matter is that, despite our pokes and prods, we are happy to have you fighting the good fight.


As to Rick Freedman’s news that a further DUI penalty would require the convicted to display pink license plates, we think this might be a good idea. However, we think the law should be extended to require Defense Attorneys who represent Defendants on a second or subsequent DUI arrest to also wear pink suits in court, so as to alert the court and prosecutor the Defendant has a prior. We think this is a good idea, merely because we just keep laughing over the thought of Jim Best in a bright pink suit arguing before a jury.


Curious wants to know:

rumpole, does your wife get on you about your blog life?

Rumpole responds: While we have briefly referenced “she who must be obeyed” we have never said we were married.


Richard Hersch, taking a break from last minute plans to
crack open the intoxilyzer (there should be a special on ABC if you guys win, like when Geraldo opened Al Capone’s safe in Miami Beach.) writes:


Your post got me thinking, Rump, and I need a moment away from the source code (yes, we broke ino CMI in the middle of the night and have had the darn thing for months.) Do I only have ONE friend?Wanted: ...friends. Must be as accepting, charming, intelligent and beautiful as my wife. Must be as engaging, fun, spontaneous and curious as my two incredible daughters (the finest children any parent could have). Must be as challenging and rewarding as my law practice. Uh...Never mind, Rump. You know what I am talking about. We like friends, but who's counting?

Rumpole commiserates: Our favorite President, Abe Lincoln, wrote:
"Common looking people are the best in the world: that is the reason the Lord makes so many of them."

Maybe your problem is that you only want to hang out with the beautiful people on south beach. Some mid-life crisis perhaps?


We note the deafening silence from the local fish wrap on their reporter's startling lack of knowledge of criminal procedure in the article yesterday. Further proof that people who write about the news are rarely the best qualified to report it.


See You In Court: NOT WEARING PINK.

Tuesday, March 07, 2006

BREAKDOWN???

We regret to report that Mr. Richard Hersch has appeared to suffer some break from reality. It’s so sad to see these once proud lions in the winter of their career. Mr. Hersch also seems to think this blog is run by the oft mentioned, formerly called “he who must not be named” Brian Tannebaum. Sorry. But Mr. Tannebaum is not the one tormenting you.

Mr. Hersch posted:

Hersch said...
Hey, I was having a senior moment and logged on to this electronic rag. First, it is spelled HERSCH, moron. Second, you can expect that Judge Newman will be the gentleman that he always is. Having recently tried a case in his division, I think that he gives pretty good latitude on introduction of evidence. In light of the subject matter presented in these source code issues, it is likely that there will be a pretty open presentation, notwithstanding the objection that the state will have to everything.Now, as for my "senior moments" I know that is you Tannebaum and if you can get permission from your mom, I will meet you at the bike racks and kick your ass.

Rumpole replies: We checked and re-checked our post Mr. Hersch and believe that we spelled your name correctly. The “senior moment” quip was ours and ours alone. Mr. Tannebaum, safely ensconced in Tallahassee, did not have his paws in that post. Somehow the thought of Mr. Tannebaum meddling in the new legislative session does not bring us much comfort. Of course, there is that old saying about not wanting to see how sausage or laws are made. As to Judge Newman, your post seems to indicate we wrote something negative about him, yet we did not. We called him a Gentleman Judge.


Finally, we have been called many things, but an electronic rag? If you want to trash us, can’t you do better than that?

Anyway, we still like you and think the drunks of Dade County who drive are in the best of hands this Thursday. We know you will do your normal great job.
(And not to add any pressure, but if you blow it, you can be sure we will print it here. Go get-em tiger.)

See You In Court, but probably not the Muldowny hearings.

AUTHOR ARTHUR!!!!!

Today, we take up our role as self appointed critic of the legal media.

Take a quick legal quiz: What’s wrong with this paragraph, as written on page 2B of our local fish-wrap Herald by reporter Ashley Fantz:


”The procedure, known as an Arthur Trial, is available to defendants held on first degree felonies facing life behind bars.”


We count three major errors, which is a lot to squeeze into one sentence.

1) Its an Arthur HEARING not an Arthur Trial.
2) The “procedure” is not a “procedure” it is a hearing, technically a bond hearing.
3) The hearing is available to any defendant held NO BOND on a first degree punishable by life felony, a life felony, and Capital cases. The hearing is NOT available to ANY defendant charged with a first degree felony facing life in prison. (Yeah, it’s “life in prison” not “life behind bars”, unless you’re Jimmy Breslin in New York.) The qualifying factor is that the defendant must be held without bond. An Arthur Hearing is all about whether there is enough proof to hold a defendant without bond, and even if there is such proof, whether the defendant a risk of flight and a danger to the community?

Call us picky, but we take pride in our profession, and the least the Herald could do is employ reporters who have a fundamental working knowledge of the criminal justice system. So far, our favorite local scribe Oh Susannah Nesmith has passed the test.


Now here’s the tricky part. An Arthur Hearing is known by several other names North of The Border (Broward) including A “You really think you’re getting a bond? hearing”; A “Motion Denied” hearing;
and our personal favorite , A “Look what the stupid lawyer from Miami wants” hearing.

Lawyers who venture North of the Border can relate to this.

You’re in court with a client being held no bond. You ask for an Arthur Hearing. The courtroom deputy snorts and controls a laugh, then ambles over to the phone (those courtrooms in Broward have phones everywhere for some reason) and calls a bunch of his buddies. And you hear him whisper “Hey, get over here quick. Some lawyer from Miami wants a bond. You gotta come see this.” The prosecutor has a wide grin on his/her face and suddenly a bunch of BSO cops fill the courtroom and you and your client are the only people in the courtroom who don’t work for Broward County. A trickle of sweat runs down your forehead as your client starts frantically whispering to you to drop it, as he doesn’t like the fact the judge has twisted the small piece of rope in his hand into a small noose.

Welcome to Broward. Now leave!


See You In Court. Just not North of The Border.

Monday, March 06, 2006

MULDOWNEY SHOWDOWN

Tension builds…the world awaits the clash of the titans.

Anonymous is a fan of Judge Newman:

Judge Newman is a perfect Judge to decide the issue. He has as much courage as any county court judge and will not be dazzled by the name Hirsch. He doesn't take sh** from people like Fat Ed, Fat Jim or Slick Dick...Bobby R. (who should be mentioned because the other DUI kings are mentioned) don't pull no sh** (like...I need a continuance because the State didn't spell Officer Davenport's name correct and I was prejudiced) and is willing to try a case. "Mitch! Bring down a panel!". I would love to see what the rate of pleas for those guys are in Judge Newman's court.You all also make a big mistake to think Judge Newman anything other than intelligent.


Rumpole responds: Judge Newman is a gentleman and the consensus from people who have tried cases in front of him is that he gives a very very fair trial. What more could you want in a Judge?


MULDOWNEY ODDS:

Anonymous, sent us an email without posting. (You knew you could do that, right? It’s on the blog. Just email
howardroark21@gmail.com and we get it without anyone else seeing it.)

ODDS ON STATE WINNING: 3-2. The Prosecution is the odds on favorite to win the motion. You will have to bet 3 dollars to win 2.

ODDS ON ALL JUDGES REMAINING THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE HEARING: 6-1. There are a whole bunch of salon/nail appointments set on Thursday afternoons, not to mention child care, Oprah, etc. Rumpole notes- the moment one judge walks off the bench, anyone taking this bet loses.

ODDS ON A MEMBER OF THE DEFENSE BEING HELD IN CONTEMPT: 60-1 They’re all pros.

ODDS ON ONE SIDE ASKING FOR A DELAY AT THE HEARING: 2-1. This usually occurs no matter what.

ODDS ON RICHARD HERSCH HAVING A SENIOR MOMENT: Off the board- no odds, we just like to have a little fun at Mr. Hersch’s expense.

Rumpole Update: As per insider Michael Catalano, who was good enough to email us a road map, Mr. Hersch is the brains of this operation, and has been ably assisted by young Assistant Public Defender Maggie Arias who has logged in the extra hours to make it all work. Bennett Brummer should be proud of her. According to Catalano, the various counties have all decided this issue differently, which means that we can all be expecting to eventually see 3rd DCA Judge Rothenberg’s decision denying the defense’s motion appealed to the Supreme Court.

As we understand the technical side of the motion, the defense contends that once the machine is opened and examined, it will be revealed that the intoxilyzer is governed by a Magic 8 Ball that when breath passes through the machine, is rocked, and the corresponding result [”probably drunk”, for example] is then translated into a random number between 0.00 and 0.30.

Good Luck Guys.

See You In Court.

JUDGE BRONWYN MILLER & JUDGE MCKENIZE OBSCURE REFERENCE

JUDGE BRONWYN MILLER GETS OPPOSITION

Alert readers posted this weekend that newly appointed County Court Judge Bronwyn Miller has received opposition from attorney George Alvarez.

A Former(?) ASA writes:

I served as an ASA with Bronwyn Miller. Yes, she is qualified, but face it.... she is a first time appointee judge up for election. She has no funds, has never run a campaign and has been a judge for only a short while. She is also a non-hispanic who is going to have a tough fight getting "re"-elected in Miami-Dade County. She is a perfect target. Remember that 99.999% of the electorate has no idea who Bronwyn Miller or Geroge Alvarez are, but are going to cast a vote anyway. It's a coin flip.

A reader wonders:

Where's captain clueless on the news that Bronwyn Miller has drawn the great legal scholar George Alvarez as opposition.

A reader wants a poll:


Poll Rump:What will the very hot Bronwyn Miller do if defeated?

A reader opines:

Regarding Judge B. Miller's competition--This is what Dade County is all about: Attempt to replace an extremely qualified, hard working competent judge with an unqualified incompetent one. To the voters of Dade, (dead and alive), FYI, South Dade Justice Center already has one incompetent lazy judge, they don't need another. Our money is on Judge B. Miller as well. We are in for 500.00

Rumpole responds to the Judge Miller race: We know Judge B Miller. She is hard working, intelligent, and will not go down without a fight. Obviously, at this moment, her biggest concern is her opponent’s name. But she can overcome that with good, aggressive campaigning. Here is the election people are wondering about: A non-hispanic female against a Hispanic male. The hope is that the election turns on qualifications. But if it doesn’t, people will be watching to see what characteristic turns out the biggest vote.



Judge Rob Pineiro said...
Sorry re: the seemingly unconnected post. But, am not all that blog adept. Post was in response to 2/26 "Best Job on Earth."Judge Pineo may blog inebriated, but I'm Judge PINEIRO so I wouldn't know. Am sober as a Judge--not one single autographed desk to my credit, as of yet.


Rumpole applauds Judge Pinero’s extremely obscure reference to former Judge Maryann McKenzie. See, we are older than most people thought. Didn’t think we would catch that did ya Judge?

Anonymous reports

I handled a case where the Bailiff for a circuit judge chased down a defendant in the hallway after an arraignment and handed him a business card for an attorney and said... hire this guy.... everything will be fine. The client came to me instead.We reported that to the SAO... they investigated and the bailiff admitted it and got to keep his job and no prosecution for that funny crime prohibiting court people from soliciting clients...Oh well. When you are part of the system... they will screw anyone to keep the system intact.

Rumpole wonders: Any criminal defense attorneys have similar stories?

A parody written by a reader:

AP-MIAMI:The recent seizure of Judicial Assistant (and future blimpie's sandwich maker) Juan D'Arce's computer has uncovered some startling finds. Among the items discovered are the CMI Intoxilyzer "source code", Fmr. U.S. Senator Thomas Eagleton's shock treatment reports, Ed Newman's real SAT scores, and Jason Grey's ego. In support of his Judicial Assistant, Judge Ivan "Semper Fi" Hernandez points out that D'Arce has a "constitutional right" to conduct political campiagns from a judge's chambers. The learned judge handed over his copy of the Constitution and directed this reporter to look up this right under the Fourth Amendment. I was unable to find either

Rumpole wonders: Why the cheap shot at Gentleman Judge Ed Newman? He is a very nice Judge. And this week he chairs the Muldowny Showdown, giving him a chance to dazzle in the DUI spotlight.

Rumpole covers the Muldowny Mayhem this week on the Blog!

Richard “the elder statesman” Hersch and Mike “not afraid to sign my name” Catalano lead a team of defense attorneys against the toughest and best the State can offer. Who will win?
How will Judge Newman handle a half dozen restless County Court Judges angry at working past noon?
Stay Tuned.
PS Any DUI lawyer who wants to post about what exactly Muldowny is? It would be appreciated. Is it just coincidence that it’s a person of Irish descent challenging the intoxilyzer? What did Muldowny blow anyway?

Anonymous wonders:

rumpole is it hard living a double life?

Rumpole responds: Yes. The constant worry, creeping in the shadows, always looking over your shoulder, life on the run is not fun. Seriously, the most difficult part of the job is when some lawyer or judge saddles over and whispers an amusing rumor. Then we need to worry: is this a red herring designed to out us? How can we print it without giving away our identity to that person? You would be amazed at the stuff we have had to sit on because only one person told us, and we couldn’t blog it.
The only regret we have is the very few times we have had to look a person we like and respect right in the eyes and deny we are the blogger. Lying is not our style, but we just don't see a way around this problem. Anyway, the identity thing has died down.
But as we recently emailed a lawyer who is obsessed with our identity,

“face it, the fact the blog is written anonymously makes it much sexier than if you knew who was writing it.”

If our identity was positively confirmed we would stop, as how could we effectively practcie before Judges who might be angry at a comment?

See You In Court denying our identity.



Friday, March 03, 2006

WAKE UP!!

NPR REPORTS:

Morning Edition, March 3, 2006 · This may explain why the Supreme Court doesn't allow cameras in the courtroom. The Court heard arguments this week over Congressional districts in Texas. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg appeared to be intently reading something during the arguments. Close observation showed she was really napping. According to Bloomberg News, the snooze lasted fifteen minutes.

Rumpole Recalls: Judge Maginnis (rest in peace) used to fall asleep in trial all the time as well. We always knew his talents were under appreciated in Dade.

Anybody have any dirt on Dade Judges napping on the Job?

YOUR LYIN EYES

Three issues today: Cops who lie; violence in prison; and trying to file a complaint against cops. We urge all prosecutors and Judges to click on the link that has the transcripts of undercover reporters trying to get a form to file a complaint. The web page may look blank, but scroll down and the transcripts of what occurred are there. Shocking.


The Honorable Roberto Pineo makes his debut on the blog, responding to term limits. (But quite frankly we couldn’t locate the post and we’d like to think his honor wasn’t drinkin and bloggin) :

Term limits for judges?! I've been publicly wearing my robe for over 16 years and still learn something new everyday (yeah,I know I leave myself open for: "Given how little he knew in the first place, he needs the time!")Nevertheless, d'y'all want a musical chair judiciary or an experienced and committed one?(I'll leave the commitment venue up to you) Judge Pineiro

Rumpole Responds: Hang on tight your Honor, these posters can be a bit rough behind the cloak of anonymity.

Jason Grey weighs in on the cop arrested for perjury:

Every ten years or so they charge a cop with perjury so state attorneys can somewhat credibly argue in closing " Why would officer so and so risk perjury charges to come in here and blah, blah, blah".Cops commit perjury all the time and almost no one cares. The cops consider untruths little white lies as long THEY believe a subject is guilty. prosecutors and Judges often look the other way. In a swearing contest between your client and a cop...well, you know . Does anyone care if a cop falsely claims something was in plain view so long as she hasn't planted it? I believe Very few cops would lie to frame a person they believe is innocent. How much does it matter when cops lie to convict people who are guilty?

Anonymous wonders:

Why don't we send Rundle's kid to boot camp??

And a poster trying to be funny writes:

It is a legal impossibility that Iven Hernandez or D'Arce operated illegally from the SDJC--THEY ARE NEVER THERE! The last time Hernandez worked on a Friday, Ford was President



SHOCKING: Go to this link, the top part of the page may be empty. Scroll down and read the transcripts of undercover reporters going into police stations and trying to get a form to file a complaint against a police officer. We particularly like the one where the police officer threatens the reporter: “take one more step forward and you will see what happens.”
HEY PROSECUTORS- GOING TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT THIS? OR ARE YOU STILL JUST GOING TO QUESTION WITNESSES WHY THEY DIDN’T FILE A COMPLAINT WHEN THEY TESTIFY THEY SAW THE OFFICER BEAT UP A DEFENDANT FOR NO REASON???

Hey Rump. Your readers should take a look at the transcripts on this link

http://cbs4.com/topstories/local_story_033170755.html

They are of copys refusing and threatening undercover reporters asking for complaint forms at various local stations. Should be prosecuted in a couple cases.
---

Why hasn't Bennett Bummer's office ever go after bad cops? When was the last time you saw Bennett, Weed, Rory, or Warren giving a press conference on the need to clean up these departments? When eas the last time anyone even heard from these hypocrites about lying cops? Thank god for attorneys like Lynn Overmann.

Rumpole Responds: what if they called a press conference and nobody came? Who would eat all the Danish?


Anonymous writes in response to the comments on the blog about what should happen to the cop arrested for perjury. These comments are well put and on the money.

All you criminal defense attorneys who are getting in line to gang rape this cop in prison are really showing your true colors. Need I remind you all of this thing called PRESUMPTION OF INNOCENCE?? Or does that only apply when you represent the defendant or when the defendant is one of you? For all those of you who are so eager to see this cop get it, maybe you should remind yourselves that one is presumed innocent until proven guilty. You all who are posting your fantasy punishment for this cop are just a bunch of HYPOCRITES. It is no wonder that criminal defense attorneys are viewed by society even lower than used car salesmen and county court judicial assistants.



Rumpole Responds: In the Federal side of things, the guidelines have enhancements for abuse of a position of trust, so police officers (and judges and attorneys) get higher sentences for committing crimes in which they abused their position. Criminal defense attorneys should be ashamed of advocating violence in prison. Violence in prison is one of the things this country should be most ashamed about. What happens to the human psyche after being exposed to danger and violence on a daily basis for a decade or so? What can we expect this person to do when released?

Also, with the high rate of innocent people being sent away ( see our previous posts on the number of innocent people sentenced to death, and then consider the other 100,000 cases nobody is looking at) violence in prison compounds the problem. Attorneys who posted and celebrated impending violence on this officer should hang their heads in shame. This officer is innocent until proven guilty, and if guilty, the punishment of a long prison sentence is sufficient without having daily acts of violence and rape to deal with.

Re Printed from the blog, originally posted January 13, 2006:


A Fallen Judge Rethinks Crime and Punishment Until 2001, Mr. Amundson, who is 56, was a highly regarded judge who sat on the Minnesota Court of Appeals, the state's second-highest court. Mentioned in legal circles as a likely nominee to the State Supreme Court…Then he was caught taking $400,000 from a trust fund he oversaw for a woman with the mental capacity of a 3-year-old, money he spent on marble floors and a piano for his house as well as model trains, sculpture and china service for 80, all bought on eBay. The Judge was prosecuted and sentenced to prison.The former Judge said: "Judges can say they have no idea what's going on in prison," Mr. Amundson said from a worn couch in the halfway house. "But if you know what's going on and you are still callous, God help you. If you are part of the system that does the things the system can do, God help you."



Violence in prison is common. Reprehensible, but common. We are seeking what thoughts any members of the judiciary have on this issue. Come on Robed Readers, many of you are intelligent and eloquent. You have a forum, so use it.

See You In Court.

Thursday, March 02, 2006

COMPUTER SEIZED???

“And some will mourn in ashes, some coal black,
For the deposing of a rightful King.” The Tragedy of King Richard the Second.

Props to Super Defender Lynn Overmann. Police arrested her client. She got the cop arrested for perjury. From the Herald article: "I think it's a bit of poetic justice that the man who wrongly arrested him has at least tasted what it feels like to be inside a jail cell" said Lynn Overmann.



JUDGE’S COMPUTER SEIZED???

The Herald reported that the office computer of everybody’s favorite whipping boy, Juan D’Arce was seized yesterday in a daring day light raid on the chambers of Judge Ivan Hernandez. However, some are whispering that His Honor’s Dell was “D’Arce’d” as well. Before we degenerate into specious speculation on what could be on that “hard” drive, lets give Judge H some props.

Many Judges would have thrown D’Arce out on his d’butt before d’herald article debuted. But Judge Ivan Hernandez stood by his employee, defended his right to campaign for the candidate of his choice, and didn’t fire D’Arce.

Loyalty. Not a trait much in evidence these days. We congratulate Judge Hernandez for standing up for his JA. If His Honor email’s us, we can recommend an honest bondsman.

OK. What could possibly be on that hard drive?

Email from D’Arce to Hernandez:

“The eagle has landed. Pericles will punish Leifman.”

Email From Hernandez to D’Arce: “Don’t get caught.”

Lexis search: “Judge/Assistant/”out of control”

West Law Search : “Ethics/Judiciary/”employee stupid enough to campaign against administrative judge”

Check out the New Poll: What Can a JA Do?

See You In Court.


Wednesday, March 01, 2006

ENOUGH

We surrender today. 41 posts. Arguments raging back and forth. Cites to the Judicial Code Of Conduct. Mostly good stuff, but we feel a bit overwhelmed. Gratified to have readers, but overwhelmed nonetheless.

However, this witty post made our day and deserves front page status:

Anonymous wrote:

When I read that D'Arce said he was targeted on Suspicion of Being Rumpole (SOBR), I nearly dropped my danish I was laughing so hard. But Rory was nearby, so I thought better of it.

Rumpole replies, observe the anatomy of a clever post: 1) It creates a new acronym SOBR, which is relevant and is hereby adopted (although we loathe the subject); 2) it references a continuing joke from our earliest days when no one was reading us. Great post, take a bow.


To the reader thoughtful enough to post the Miami “no credit” Herald article written by a woman who has been banned from the blog- since we banned her, we will not reprint her trite tripe. We are not referring to our favorite Herald scribe Oh Susannah, but that writer of tepid talk of the town.

D’Arce is done. He has been examined more thoroughly than Dick Cheney’s shotgun. Hopefully, tomorrow brings new topics.


See You In Court.

DBR ARTICLE ON D'ARCE

Anonymous was good enough to post this on the message board this morning:

From Today's DBR:The Miami-Dade state attorney’s office has launched a criminal investigation into whether the judicial assistant to a Miami-Dade County Court judge extorted judges to get them to hire him as a campaign consultant. According to sources close to the investigation, Richard Scruggs, special assistant for public corruption at the office, is looking into that charge as well as charges that Juan D’Arce, judicial assistant to Judge Ivan Hernandez, did private consulting work while on his judicial assistant job. ...

Sources said prosecutors seized D’Arce’s computer as part of the investigation, which D’Arce denies. ...

Bob Levy, campaign consultant to a handful of judges up for re-election, said several of his judicial clients were called by D’Arce. “He said if they didn’t hire him, he would run someone against them,” Levy said. “People feel in fear. This is extortion and intimidation.” D’Arce, 34, acknowledged in an interview that he has worked for judicial candidates in past years, including Diane Ward, Judy Rubenstein, Peter Adrien, Gabriel Martin and Ivan Fernandez, and has set up a corporation to do political consulting, called Pericles. “It’s from Greek mythology — he invented the voting system,” D’Arce said.

But D’Arce insists that he has never contacted a judge, asked for money or done work while at the courthouse. “This is a smear campaign,” he said. “Yeah, I dislike some judges and would like to see them out. But I have every right to do this on my own time. I get approached by people all the time.” One candidate who recently hired D’Arce is Juan F. Gonzalez, who is running against County Court Judge Steven Leifman. Gonzalez said D’Arce “works with me, he’s helping me.” ... He said he only does political work on his own time, and only sometimes asks for pay.

He said he is being targeted because many in the legal community believe he writes the anonymous blog, justicebuilding.blogspot, which he insists he does not. ...

For his part, Judge Ivan Hernandez, for whom D’Arce works, said he has no problem with D’Arce working for political candidates on his own time “as long as he doesn’t use my office. And he hasn’t.” “I don’t think it’s against the law,” Hernandez said. “He has a constitutional right … to freedom of speech.”

Rumpole replies: We watched with detached bemusement as this story hit the blog and message boards. But for this two bit political wannabe to try and say that anybody would think D’Arce has the ability to write this blog….which if nothing else is written by an attorney with at least a modicum of intelligence and wit…well that really frosts our ass a little bit.

We may not be much more than a Justice Building Hack, but we like to think this blog has, at least at times, exhibited some nice writing, some funny lines, and some thoughtful comments on important issues like civil rights, the death penalty (which admittedly have bored readers to tears ) and Rory Stein’s snack habits. For this self important JA to allege that anyone would think he would have the inclination, imagination, and mental acuity to write some of the pieces we have written, well, we hope he gets what’s coming to him.

D’Arce appears to be living in somewhat of a fantasy world, believing he is a mover, shaker, intimidator of Judges, and sought after political consultant. Only someone living in a fantasy world would believe for one moment that the stuff we print here is important enough to merit an investigation. (Although we have kept a wary eye out for former Judge Milian because of our comments that her husband sought to become a judge just to be able to order her around.) But outside of her, we are under no illusions that our humble little blog serves any greater purpose than to allow some members of the Miami criminal legal community to discuss the issues in our little world [ and to allow free political advertisement for Judge Shelly Schwartz. But we love Shelly, so we post his stuff even though we know what he’s up to. ]

In summary, we cherish our anonymity, but if someone is going to try and take credit for our blog, we’d rather it be Roy Black or Stephen Hawkings, not some dimwitted dofus.

See You In Court.

Tuesday, February 28, 2006

DOG PILE ON THE JA

The CAPTAIN reports:Update on Group 9 of the County Court:Victoria del Pino has finally drawn opposition. I am pleased to report that the five year attorney (del Pino) will now face off against an actual veteran of the bar, with 8 years of experience, one Joel S. Jacobi, of North Miami.There have been no other changes to the races reported in County or Circuit Court and fundraising reports are not due for the next reporting quarter until March 31, 2006.Rump:I would like to get a poll going on Election vs. Appointment; what do you think?Of course, I think some of your bloggers would prefer duels by firearm, LSAT score comparison, or just plain fistacuffs to a good ole election.and the Captain has spoken ........


Captain has his detractors:

Dear CaptainYou bug me.


ON JA HIJINKS: Someone had replaced BHB as public enemy number Uno. Not many denizens of the REG Justice Building have any sympathy for JA politico wannabe D’Arces, as this collection of posts demonstrate:


Well, well, well, how the mighty have fallen. Wasn't it Jimmy Durante who said, "Be careful who you step on on the way up, you'll meet those same people on the way down." I know EXACTLY of who you speak, and I can guarantee you, it sounds just like his style. So ready to rat others out while his hands remain dirty. This news will make me smile all day, and for those who know me...that's saying something.

---

You know, I would love to be sympathetic, but I left it in my other suit. I wonder how much KY it's going to take to get him out of THIS one...
---

Anonymous hearkens back to the Senate Watergate hearings, and quotes Senator Howard Baker about D’Arces’s employer:

What did Ivan know and when did he know it?


Anonymous writes:

Hey Rumpy. I can't stand that JA. He's mean, manipulative, and extorts people. Ivan H. should run away from him like the plague. Why don't you tip this to your girlfriend from the Herald and let her investigate it? We need details!!!

Rumpole responds: Girlfriend??? Well, she is kinda tall and slinky in all the right places, but “she who must be obeyed” would not be pleased. We have it on good authority Oh Susannah peruses these pages frequently.


The Empire (Of Ticket Attorneys) Strikes Back:[re our comment calling them nameless and faceless]


Hey, those of us who work on the first floor are not nameless and faceless. you just may never see anything but our backs as we scurry from ct. to ct. because no one in the clerk's office has figured that staggering court times would be beneficial to everyone. (they're not waiting in line at the metal detector at 8:59). We're also the ones that you big felony guys turn to once a year when you're handling your mother-in-law's case and you have no clue whether the officer used the right statute or if the hearing officer will dismiss if they spelled her name wrong. (for the third time, NO.)

Rumpole replies: May the force be with you.


We conclude tonight’s post, pondering about hubris, of which we have written about previously (Brummer Bummer) and Mr. D’Arces. And as is our wont, we return to the great Bard, who provides us with words when our little mind fails us:

“The Fault, Dear Brutus, lies not in our stars, but in ourselves.” Julius Caesar.

See You In Court, quoting the Bard, when the moment is right

JA HI JINKS

Submitted for your consideration, one Mr. Juan D'Arce, Jr., JA to a Judge in South Dade County Court.

Depending on who you talk to, Mr. D'Arce is doing the following:
1) Campaigning against sitting administrative Judge Steve Leifman while on county time;
2) Calling other Judges and candidates and soliciting work for himself as a publicist , while on county time;
3) No accusation yet that he has been selling perfume, while on county time.

Mr. D’Arce, JA, political wanabee, hustling while on county time????
Welcome to the Twilight Zone.

People have confirmed the investigation. Depending on whom we speak to, the exact parameters of the investigation is unknown. Rumors are, even the Daily Business Review will have a small piece on the ever expanding problems of Mr. D'Arce.

Stay Tuned.

Monday, February 27, 2006

JA IMPROPRIETY??

Breaking News: There's a JA To A County Court Judge in South Dade that is rumored to be in more than a bit of hot water for working very hard for Judge Steve Leifman's opponent while on County time. We are getting emails that say this JA is the mean spirited one who spilled the beans on Lefiman's JA selling perfume. Just another day or so, a few more sources, and names will be named.

But this JA, he knows who we're talking about.

See You In Court. But Not South Dade.

BEST JOB ON EARTH????

Our Favorite duplicitously named reader, Gayle Gayle, sends this missive about judges, elections, and Dade County: Due to the length of the post, we employee a favorite technique and respond inside brackets [ ] in the post.

Hi Rumpy- did you catch the latest Florida Bar News-Dade County Judges crying in their beer about people challenging them for their judgeships [you can be sure that any judge crying in their beer didn’t pick up the tab at the bar]

-allegations that they are being targeted based on ethnicity and/or race or the ability to raise money-the arrogance-who are they to say they are the only ones qualified to be a judge [umm… they are the judge, so they're the ones to say it. Everything they say is tinged with the wisdom of Solomon] -who gave them the life estate just because in some time past they either had the political connections to be appointed or were of the right ethnicity to win an election – [if a judge wants a lifetime appointment, move to Broward, where even Judge Aleman gets re-elected.]

how dare they be offended when someone else thinks that they too might be qualified to be a judge and therefore challenges them in an election – [Listen Gayle Gayle- we like you, but lets face it. These people running for Judge aren’t necessarily qualified. They just are elect-able. And in truth, isn’t that always the reason someone runs for election? Sheesh, but If our name was Jane Schwartz-Hernandez, we’d probably run for Judge as well.]

yes the demographics of Dade County has changed-and yes an individual with a Hispanic surname has an advantage at the polls-but many of these sitting judges didn’t mind taking advantage of the demographics when they were in their favor years ago-[100% on the money with this zinger]

Judge Lando points out that if she puts in enough money in her account then she can deter someone from running against her-so by that logic money buys you a judgeship-[as Gomer Pyle used to say “surprise surprise surprise!!!]

well maybe ethnicity is the equalizer to money-why shouldn’t someone who doesn’t have the political connections or the money have a equal chance, at what former Judge Sorrondo characterizes as "the best job on earth"- being a judge-the problem could be solved with term limits for judges-two terms-twelve years-that’s enough time for someone to be on the bench-let other qualified people have a chance who as i have said before may not have the political connections to be appointed or the money to essentially buy a judgeship-the present judiciary would like to keep it a closed club -times are a changing rumpy -ta ta

Rumpole responds: It is human nature to try and close the door once you get in. Look, if we ponied up the 200 grand to run for Judge and won, we would be the first to support changing the system to merit retention.


As to Judge Sorrondo, we like him, we respect him, but we firmly believe the person who chooses the Playboy centerfolds each month has the best job on earth. Owning a Las Vegas casino ain’t that bad either.

This topic is always on people’s minds, but how much more can be said?


The fact is that its tough to make an honest buck as an attorney.

[Obligatory list of complaints to follow:]

Chasing clients for cash, swatting bondsmen away from hustling your clients to dirty attorneys is a constant headache; getting yelled at by JA’s (not judges but their assistants) when you try and schedule a hearing is demeaning. Waiting for 2 hours to see your client in the clean and comfy confines of the dade county jail (only to be told that “he’s escaped again” ) is not fun. Throw in support staff that needs constant monitoring, running a business, taxes, accountants, and who has time to read case law and try cases? Don’t forget the bar requires an immediate response to every disgruntled client’s bar complaint. (true story- one client filed a bar complaint, after a NOT GUILTY verdict because we didn’t return a phone call about getting his property back the following week quickly enough) and after 10 or 15 years of this hilarity and fun, sitting on the bench for several grand a month starts to seem attractive.

PLUS once you’re on the bench an amazing transformation occurs.

Amnesia.

History is re-written.

All of the sudden, you, as Judge, used to be the lawyer who tried more cases than Sy Gaer. You had clients beating your doors down. Every case had motions promptly filed, and you were ready for trial on the first trial date-every time. In the rare case that wasn’t tried (and won) within 30 days of being hired (when your large fee was paid in full) your motion for continuance was promptly filed, with copies served on every prosecutor and defense attorney within the 305 and 786 area codes. Plus, every motion had a full five page memorandum on the law in Florida, and cites to cases in the several nearby states, including wise commentary on how the supreme court would decide every case on its pending docket.

Yes, as we see it, the very best thing about becoming a Judge is what is does to your former career as an attorney. Becoming a Judge made you (as an attorney) the smartest, most prepared, hardest working, financially successful, trial lawyer who ever was.

Our concluding advice to our robed readers, is, that maybe Rudy Sorrondo was right. Being a judge is the best job on earth, or at least the best job in Miami’s legal community.


So Dear Robed Readers, buckle up, raise that moolah, and hire those political consultants, because every Tom, Dick, and Marisol is gunning for your job.

But if you do lose, just remember how great an attorney you were. Just recall all those lectures you gave from the bench about how easy it is to schedule motions for continuance on the Thursday before the Tuesday before the Monday following the sounding date. And just remember what it was like to have a Judge start trial at 4PM, and conduct voire dire till 10PM, and have you back in court the next day at 9:30.

See You In Court, doing what we love most.

LBJ, Shelly Schwartz and Left Hook Al.


Query: What do Judge Sheldon Schwartz and the 36th President of the United States have in common?



President Johnson, tired of the “Hey Hey LBJ, How many kids did you kill today?” chants in the park across from the White House, said this:

I shall not seek, and I will not accept the nomination of my party for another term as your president."

Judge Sheldon Schwartz posted this on the blog:

Please; I do not wish to nor would I replace Judge Steve Leifman as the administrative person in charge of the traffic magistrates. I do believe such is a thankless position. Being an administrative judge is difficult and truly a thankless position. It is hoped that when a person becomes a judge or magistrate they have the ability to be independent thinkers and decision makers within the parameters of the law. Judge Leifman can't be blamed for the failures of others. Judge Leifman cannot be in every traffic magistrates court to watch over each of their rulings nor should he be.As a judge I have the opportunity to provide justice in the courts of our community. I listen to the facts and make the decision based upon the facts presented. I want people to understand what happens in a court ,whether represented or unrepresented. I wish for people to leave the court believing I was fair albeit not everyone leaves happy. I at least attempt to explain the reasons for my decision be it in civil infractions, criminal traffic violations, domestic violence matters and even uncontested dissolution of marriage matters.But as the song title goes,"I did it my way” providing what I believe to be justice.

So no thanks.
Judge Shelly Schwartzp.s.
Yes, I do view the log periodically.


Rumpole responds 1: The Lord of the Traffic Magistrates has yet to address the criticism and invectives hurled his way by the denizens of the traffic ticket world. You know who we mean. Those nameless, faceless attorneys who scurry between courtrooms starting with "1" which are seldom seen outside of the eyes of the motorcycle cop and the hapless 78 year old grandmother he stopped for speeding away from the bingo hall on her way to the 4:30 early bird. You, Judge Schwartz, may read and occasionally post on this humble blog, but the Lord Of Traffic Magistrates does not deign to bend down and post a response to his critics.

2: Not only do you- Judge Schwartz -“occasionally” read the blog, but you have replaced Judge Young as the most prolific poster among the robed readers. [However, Judge Young may be the first Robed Reader to leave a post in his own name, and for that we applaud his courage.] However, this business of getting ringers- attorneys to write in and extol your virtues, has to stop. You already have our support.


A reader “North Of the Boarder” (Broward) has a say:

I have been reading the website for the past several weeks and I have noted our dysfunctional family’s ever more virulent attacks on Bennett Brummer. While I am not now, nor have I ever been a member of the Public Defender’s Office, these attacks on BHB strike me as somewhat shortsighted. I practice extensively in Broward County and it has always struck me that the difference between practice in Miami, where “justice” is not just a word hidden in Webster’s, but an actual concept followed by all of the players (prosecutors, defense bar and judges) involved, at least most of the time, and Broward, where justice is rarely found, was because of the strong philosophical lead provided by Janet Reno, Bennett Brummer and a strong and vigorous defense bar. I guess you all would rather have the lead being provided by Michael “You May Not Have Committed This Offense, But You Must Be Guilty of Something” Satz and Alan “Let’s Spend the P.D.’s Money on Margarita Parties” Schreiber, not to mention Chief-fascist Dale Ross.Sorry, folks, but from where I sit, BHB’s lawyers are the ones that help the system run as fairly to those “accused” of committing crimes as it does. Look at the people who work for him; for the most part, they are dedicated, experienced and talented lawyers. If you don’t believe that the system is more fairly applied in our little courthouse, try a few weeks sitting in courtroom north of our border.Oh, and by the way, does anybody find it ironic (read, funny) that Al “I’ll Punch The Lights Out of Any Defense Attorney Who Crosses Me/ Or Any Lobotomized Juror Who Doesn’t Vote Guilty” Milian was busy calling the prosecutor’s case in the Broward’s Sheriff officer’s fake statistics matter a “prosecution looking for a case”? Sorry, but that cat is not changing his spots!

Rumpole Responds: Welcome dear reader from North of the boarder. You are welcome to pause here during your difficult days and find succor and drink from the well of Dade County. Your neck of the woods is reserved for the brave and foolhardy. You practice in a world where Judges (Aleman) do not let terminally ill defendants out of county jail to die at home with some peace and dignity (although the margarita soirées at the PD’s office sound kinda nice).

Currently you have let Left Hook Al Milian loose on us and he has set his sights on the judiciary in Dade. Do you think he will take a swing at Judge Farina if he doesn’t get the judicial assignment he wants? Or are his fist-a-cuffs confined to defense attorneys? "Motion to supress huh? First you have to fight me."


See You In Court. Not Traffic Ticket Court. We haven’t been to a courtroom that started with a “1” since Arthur Rothenberg was doing DUI’s.

Friday, February 24, 2006

OF RACISM, VOTING AND SPIES

Jason Grey is in his usual mood, and has a simple question:


why does everything in this stupid, backwater, cultureless banana republic come down to race? It's idiotic to vote for someone because of their race. It is insulting to group people by color. As if, all black people feel the same about all Issues, or all Jewish people would do the same thing under a particular set of circumstances, and don’t even try to group Hispanics, A label that includes at least 30 subcultures. The founding fathers had it right. voting is too important to be left to the masses, That's how we ended up with our current Idiot in chief.Voters should have to pass an exam on the issues before being allowed to cast a ballot. Other wise you get morons in office because their name sounded right.


Rumpole responds: Just what Florida needs, another layer between a citizen and the ballot box. Can you just see the headlines now? People rioting as the same people who administer the FCAT grade tests to see who votes, with county court judges grading the essay portion of the test.


And a reader responds:


or we could just start a poll tax jason. you think bush won because of the uneducated? no way. the rich people voted for him because they thought they could have more money/less taxes. we want everyone to be able to vote. but we want informed elections. our judge elections are not informed at all. that's the problem -- not that dumbies are allowed to vote.

Rumpole admits: We try and help our readers by spell checking their posts, but misspelling “dummy”? Well, not to rhyme, but that was too funny.

Blog hint: Write your post on Word, spell check, cut and paste.


And another reader writes:

Natalie Holloway WAS pretty good-looking. Also, on Jason Grey's point, I'm glad to see somebody coming around to my view that the vote must be restricted. I believe only property owners ought to be afforded the vote. When you allow the vote to extend to folks you have little to no stake in society (other than to take from it), it's predictable what type of governance you'll get.



The Lord Of The Traffic Magistrates has spies in his midst’s:

A spy reports:

Another Judge Is Required To Clean Up The Mess Made By The Supervisor Of The Traffic Magistrates. The Magistrates Have Been Directed To Penalize Persons Who Wish To Proceed To Trial Or Even Set Their Matters For Trial.Magistrates Adjudicate On Many First Offenses; Yes Even Seat Belt Violations And Impose Fines In Excess Of 350 Dollars. This Is As A Result Of Judge Leifman’s Direction. Are People Not Entitled To A Trial, Non-Jury Trial Taking Probably Less Than Ten Minutes Without Being Punished Severely?
Especially When Having A Good Record? We Submit, The Law Requires Justice And Not Severe Sanctions For Going To Or Electing To Set A Matter For Trial.
We Do Thank The System For Placing A Fair Judge To Doing The Mitigations Of The Mess.T.B.



Rumpole responds: Sounds like someone wants Shelly Schwartz to replace the Lord Of the Traffic Magistrates. Judge Leifman probably has a thankless job. But it would be nice if he responded to these allegations that he directs traffic magistrates to rule a particular way. We are willing to give him the benefit of the doubt that there is another side to this story. How about it Judge L? Want to respond. Judge Shelly Schwartz can email you the link, as readers all know Judge Schwartz reads and responds to this blog, eloquently at times.

Judge David Young writes with breaking news:

BIG NEWS....BREAKING NEWS....Sy Gear asked for discovery! Yes it is true. I was honored to participate in such a historic event.


Rumpole responds: We tend to post any drivel a Judge sends us, because it's a Judge and we can't resist taking a cheap shot.
OK, to get in the spirit of Judge Young's email, Sy is great isn't he? A one of a kind Justice Building Original.
In reality though, Sy often asks for disco- he just doesn't take depos. But as legions of young ASA's have learned, he is dangerous with a police report, a few notes, and a worn out pencil. And juries love him.


See You In Court studying for the voting test and avoiding Judge Young because we were so grouchy towards him.


Wednesday, February 22, 2006

12 STEPS TO REOVERY FROM ADDICTION TO THIS BLOG.

Several readers have a problem. Admitting they have a problem is the first step to recovery.
Anonymous confessed:

i think i have justice building blog addiction.

And another reader also confessed:

I'm addicted too. Is there some type of support group we should join

Rumpole helps out:


THE 12 STEPS TO RECOVERY FROM BEING ADDICTED TO THIS BLOG

1. We admitted we were powerless over the BLOG. That our lives had become unmanageable, our caseloads exploded, as we spent more and more time on the blog
instead of work.

2. We came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves [Bennett H Brummer] could restore us to sanity by restricting our daytime access to the blog.


3. We made a decision to turn our careers over to the care of Stein and Brummer as we understood them.

4. We made a searching and fearless inventory of ourselves and why we could not get through the day without a bit of wisdom from Jason Grey, or reading about the latest attack on Bobby Reiff.

5. We admitted to Bennett Brummer all the posts we made on the blog about him.

6. We were entirely ready to have Bennett Brummer remove the Justice Building link to the Blog from our “Favorites” on our web browser.

7. We humbly asked Him [BHB] to remove our negative posts about him.

8. We made a list of all persons we had slammed on the blog , and became willing to make amends to them all.

9. We made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do so would injure them or cause Bobby Reiff to sue us.

10. We continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong on a blog post, we promptly admitted it.

11. We Sought through prayer and meditation to stay away from the blog, improve our opinion of Bennett Brummer, praying only for knowledge and the power to stay away from the blog, or at least spell check our posts before posting them.

12. We, having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, tried to carry this message to others addicted to the blog, and to practice these principles in all our affairs.

Good Luck with the addiction. See You In Court.

No truth to the rumor Judge Rosinek will be conducting a "blog court" for those attorneys caught and prosecuted for posting on the blog.

PSS: We received a very nice email from a REGJB Judge who told us that s/he reads the blog often and so do many civil court Judges. So what does that mean? Well, among other things, we have to stop using words with more than three syllables .

Why is it that even when a robed reader goes out of their way to be nice to us, we have to take a cheap shot? Probably years of resentment spilling out. Maybe we need a 12 step program. "Judge Jabbers Annonymous" Anyway, in all seriousness, thanks for the compliment Judge.




THESE POLLS ARE DOWN AND DONE

THE BLOG STAYS AS IS:


"SHOULD THE BLOG BE CHANGED?"
LEAVE IT AS IT IS
27 votes
ONLY POST READER COMMENTS WITH WITTY REPLIES
3 votes
JUST POST TOPICS AND STOP RE-POSTING READERS COMMENTS
6 votes
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
5 votes
I'M BENNET BRUMMER AND YOUR DAYS ARE NUMBERED ANYWAY
14 votes
MORE BOBBY REIFF AND BRIAN TANNEBAUM STUFF
5 votes
CHANGE BLOG TO "JASON GREY'S THOUGHT OF THE DAY"
7 votes
WHEN YOUR IDENTITY IS REVEALED YOU ARE FINISHED IN THIS TOWN.
8 votes


BENNETT NEEDS SOME GOOD PR PEOPLE:

"WHO IS BEST MIAMI PD?"
BENNETT BRUMMER
19%
28 votes
KATHY WILLIAMS
81%
121 votes


BENNETT GETS EX-XFL’ER JERSEY “HE HATE ME” AS THE PRIZE.

"BENNETT BRUMMER:"
LOVE HIM (current PD employee)
21 votes
LOVE HIM (not employed with PDs)
15 votes
OK FOR A POLITICIAN
19 votes
GOT CAUGHT PULLING A FAST ONE
49 votes
HATE HIM (current PD employee)
56 votes
HATE HIM (not employed by PDs)
70 votes


SY IS THE MAN


"WHO DOES A BETTER JOB IN COURT?"
PD
27%
44 votes

COURT APPOINTNED ATTORNEY
19%
31 votes


SY GAER

90 votes
55%


Post any ideas for new polls.

See You In Court




Tuesday, February 21, 2006

Oogle

Anonymous quoted Ike:

"Should any political party attempt to abolish social security, unemployment insurance, and eliminate labor laws and farm programs, you would not hear of that party again in our political history. There is a tiny splinter group, of course, that believes that you can do these things. Among them are a few Texas oil millionaires, and an occasional politician or businessman from other areas. Their number is negligible and they are stupid."--President Dwight D. Eisenhower, 1952


Doubleya responded:











You talking to me?


HORNETS NEST: OGLE MANIA: Rumpole says, lets get off racism and back to sexism, which is more....sexy.


Talk about opening a can of worms:

Anonymous responded to a comment about an attractive young PD:

Complementary comments regarding women lawyers should be controlled with the same rigor as disparaging comments. This blog cannot be a mask from behind which to anonymously ogle.

Let the fun begin.

See You In Court not oogling anyone. We Google, but don't oogle.

PS: Final poll tallys for polls removed will be posted this week. Stay tuned.



Sunday, February 19, 2006

MARTIN LEE ANDERSON AND RACISM

We were gratified to see conversation and comment on our post on the murder of 14 year old Martin Lee Anderson. The issue quickly devolved into a discussion of racism.

As this post shows:

Come off it with the racism crap.I'm lily white and I'm sickened.I'm not denying that racism is pervasive and institutional. But here, in this situation, arguing that Martin Anderson is dead because of racism amounts to paranoid incitement. Representatives Barreiro and Gelber, among the first to see the tape, described the beating as "brutal," "disturbing" and "heinous." Neither are black.


We think this post by Captain hits the nail right on the head:


Rump has stirred the emotions of several bloggers with his first shot about the Martin Lee Anderson death.Here is the "racism" that some of you seem to be missing:On May 30, 2005, a beautiful blonde haired blue eyed teenager disappeared from a foreign country. Only a few days later, the entire country - and the world - new about the disappearance. And for the next several months, every single evening on TV, we watched. We watched Larry King on CNN, and that fat mouthed ugly bitch former prosecutor (sorry but I just can't stand Nancy Grace) on CNN/Headline News, and Joe Scarborough on MSNBC's Scarborough Country and, worst of all, Greta Van Susteren - on Fox's On The Record, cover this story every single day - month after month after month. The only thing that finally stopped the coverage was Hurricane Katrina.Now, we have a young black teenager, beaten to death in our own country, on video, by the police; the medical examiner from another county does the autopsy, and he makes ridiculous findings, and I have to ask the following question:Where is Larry, where is Nancy, Where is Joe, and where is Greta - why - because, guess what fellow bloggers, Martin Lee Anderson did not die in the last few days. For those of you who did not realize it, Martin Lee Anderson died on January 6, 2006 - THAT IS 43 DAYS AGO - and we are now finally hearing about the story.I look forward to the news shows this week to see if any of them even give minimal coverage to the story - or whether Greta will be back this week interviewing the mother or father Holloway on the new lawsuit that they filed last week against the wienersnautchen family. I guess it will take another Katrina to get that story off the air again.There's your racism people ....and the Captain has spoken.....

Rumpole says, well written Captain. Racism was not behind the brutal murder of Martin Lee Anderson. As another post notes, the video shows black and white guards beating Anderson. But racism may well be behind the investigation and prosecution. Martin Lee Anderson was not blond, blue eyed, and sexy like Natalee Holloway, and yet by virtue of the media coverage, you would think she was the only person murdered last year.


Anonymous makes an excellent point on institutional racism:

Black officers are often times the ones most effected by institutionalracism. You don't have to be whiteto be racist. Blacks are often times just as racist towards otherblacks as whites.So to say that because both white and black officers beat Martin, does not mean that they were noteffected by racism.The racism crap you refer to is real. Either way, if you actually read my comments, I never saidMartin was dead because of racism.I said that the pathetic response by Bush and the Government is another example of institutionalized racism at work.Don't be so simple minded.

Anonymous clears up a point in our post:

In saying this kid was in for "grand theft auto", the reader might mistakenly come to the conclusion that the perpetrator was a young thug. Here, the kid was joyriding in his Grandmother's car.

This post gets honorable mention as it made us laugh:

The reason no one commented on the Rosa Parks post is because most of the people reading this blog checked CJIS for her name and found nothing, and then figured she got tranferred to civil in the last judicial rotation.


Rumpole praises “Oh” Susannah the Herald’s courthouse scribe for a nice article on the capital murder case before Judge Blake. But Rumpole notes, almost anyone can memorize a jury chart, and we think the time and energy spent in doing that takes a lawyer away from more important tasks during voire dire. But give ASA Gayle Levine her due, she knows what she’s doing.

More importantly, we wonder did Herald Scribe “Oh” Susannah miss, leave out, or did she just not know about the taped phone calls of the defendant in the DCJ in which he calls his previous attorneys the N word and makes disparaging remarks about Jewish lawyers? Oh well, maybe she should consult us more often about her stories to see if we have any hot tips.


See You In Court. Happy President’s Day.