JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG

WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL RICHARD E GERSTEIN JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG. THIS BLOG IS DEDICATED TO JUSTICE BUILDING RUMOR, HUMOR, AND A DISCUSSION ABOUT AND BETWEEN THE JUDGES, LAWYERS AND THE DEDICATED SUPPORT STAFF, CLERKS, COURT REPORTERS, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS WHO LABOR IN THE WORLD OF MIAMI'S CRIMINAL JUSTICE. POST YOUR COMMENTS, OR SEND RUMPOLE A PRIVATE EMAIL AT HOWARDROARK21@GMAIL.COM. Winner of the prestigious Cushing Left Anterior Descending Artery Award.

Friday, September 14, 2012

MISTAKES AND mistakes

Judge Will Thomas had to declare a mistrial Thursday in the Lebron trial. This case occurred in 2002. It has been to the 3rd DCA and back once and Lebron- accused of being the shooter- has waited while other co-defendants who were severed went to trial before him. 

The facts of the case- a kidnapping, sexual assault and murder are particularly disturbing. It could not have been easy for the mother of Ana Maria Angel, the young woman murdered, to learn of the mis-trial. She has endured more than almost any of us ever will, and has waited a decade for this person to go to trial. Judge Thomas by all accounts handled the mistrial in a professional yet sensitive matter. The mistrial occurred when a detective volunteered information that a co-defendant had gone to trial and been convicted. Mr. Lebron is entitled to a fair trial and the testimony of the detective- not solicited by the prosecutor- would have jeopardized that.   Nobody wants this case to take another decade by being over turned on appeal. Here's hoping that when the trial re-starts next Wednesday it proceeds quickly and cleanly. 

PD/FACEBOOK
We avoided posting on the PD/Facebook fiasco the other day because we didn't want to fan the flames of publicity. The young woman involved made a mistake. People do that. Even lawyers. Sometimes even the best of us make a bad judgment and do something that on retrospect we know to be wrong. That is what occurred here. The PD paid for her mistake with her job. We think that is wrong. By all accounts she was a very good advocate for the clients she represented. Hard working and not afraid to go to trial. The Herald wrote the story, news outlets picked it up- the "Legal Briefs" headline was irresistible to the news media writing about a case where a lawyer posted a picture of her client's silly looking underwear. The news even made it to the London Daily Mail.  Enough is enough.  There isn't a lawyer who has ever tried a case who hasn't in a moment of pressure, frustration, or tiredness, done or said a stupid thing they immediately wished they hadn't. But in 2012 the rise of instantaneous social media connectivity means those mistakes get publicized around the world at the speed of light. We wish the PD well. Based on her excellent reputation before this matter, we would have no qualms about having her sit with us the next time we go to trial. This will pass and she will bounce back. 

FOOTBALL POOL WEEK TWO UPDATED AS OF 2PM-The overwhelmingly popular pick is the NE Cheaters. We hope they get crushed at home by the mighty Arizona Cardinals. 

Football Pool 2012 Pdf2 Enjoy your weekend. COURTS CLOSED MONDAY for the celebration of the Jewish New Year. 

See you in court on Tuesday. 

Thursday, September 13, 2012

BEST PIZZA IN MIAMI

BREAKING: MISTRIAL! Judge William Thomas declared a mistrial in the Lebron case this (Thursday) afternoon as a detective apparently made a refence to the trial and conviction of a co-defendant. More on this obviously heartbreaking and frustrating development as it becomes available.
Herald/Ovalle article on mistrial here.
Retrial with jury selection to begin again next Wednesday.



Harry's- in the Design District- has been tagged as one of the "Best New Pizza Places in the US" in this  Huffington Post on line article. 
                         (Chef Michael Schwartz's Trugole  pie)

Your choice? 

REMINDER: Get your suicide pool picks in. Week two starts with Da Bears at Packers Thursday night football tonight. 

PCA'd.
Getting PCA'd after spending a year working on an appeal stinks. A quick check of the 3rd DCA's opinions issued wednesday shows 24 PCAs and ONE written opinion (and in that opinion they wrote to cut off a prisoner's ability to file anymore appeals.) Not a great day at the 3rd DCA for the defense. 

Lebron Murder Trial:
Just follow @davidovalle305 on twitter for updates on the gruesome Lebron murder/kidnapping/sexual battery trial. He is sitting through the entire horrific case.  The hashtag is #AnaMariaAngel. 

See You In Court. 




Wednesday, September 12, 2012

OPENINGS AND CLOSINGS

Opening Statements today at the REGJB in State v. Lebron, the horrific kidnapping, murder, sexual assault case where the prosecution is seeking the death penalty. Reid Ruben, Christine Zahralban,  and Laura Adams for the the prosecution, Jeff Fink for the first phase and Raphael Rodriguez for the penalty phase for the defense. 

What did Bush Know and when did he know it? 
Kurt Eichenwald in the NY Times Tuesday says that the president's team had more advance notice beyond the infamous August 6th briefing where the president was told "Bin Laden determined to strike US." 

The problem: The CIA was warning the president and his team of an impending attack, while the "Neo-Cons" who had their eyes on unfinished business in Iraq, were dismissive of the warnings. A clear case of not wanting to believe what you don't want to believe, despite what the evidence shows:  

By May 1, the Central Intelligence Agency told the White House of a report that “a group presently in the United States” was planning a terrorist operation. Weeks later, on June 22, the daily brief reported that Qaeda strikes could be “imminent,” although intelligence suggested the time frame was flexible...
But some in the administration considered the warning to be just bluster. An intelligence official and a member of the Bush administration both told me in interviews that the neoconservative leaders who had recently assumed power at the Pentagon were warning the White House that the C.I.A. had been fooled; according to this theory, Bin Laden was merely pretending to be planning an attack to distract the administration from Saddam Hussein, whom the neoconservatives saw as a greater threat...
In response, the C.I.A. prepared an analysis that all but pleaded with the White House to accept that the danger from Bin Laden was real.
“The U.S. is not the target of a disinformation campaign by Usama Bin Laden,” the daily brief of June 29 read...
On July 24, Mr. Bush was notified that the attack was still being readied, but that it had been postponed, perhaps by a few months. But the president did not feel the briefings on potential attacks were sufficient, one intelligence official told me, and instead asked for a broader analysis on Al Qaeda, its aspirations and its history. In response, the C.I.A. set to work on the Aug. 6 brief.
So here is what history is showing us: an administration that started a war with faulty intelligence about Saddam Hussein having WMDs, was also an administration that allowed the United States to be attacked because it ignored increasingly frantic warnings from its intelligence agency. Why were the warnings ignored? Because they didn't fit within the foreign policy/political goals of  select members of the administration who, having worked for Bush 41,  had a decades old score to settle with Saddam Hussein- who we now know presented no threat to the United States. 
If President Obama and his team made even one of the mistakes that riddled the Bush administration, they would be called traitors and Republicans would be crying for their arrest and prosecution. 
The more things change...
See You In Court. 




Monday, September 10, 2012

IN THE DARK

Update: The lights are back on 90 miles south of Key West. An embarrassed communist party member tripped over an extension cord. All is back to normal.

Power failure in Havana last night. Have to wonder how long those old communists can hold on. 

Query: When Cuba opens up, it will be 
a) good for Miami's economy in general
b) good for the legal community's  economy
c) bad for Miami's economy in general
d) bad for the legal community's economy
e) no effect 

Dolphins started off 0-1 Sunday  on their way to 3-13 or worse. 

Semi-controversy in Broward where Judge Diaz, facing a stiff re-election challenge has taken to swearing in jurors every week. Jurors that just happen to be drawn from the pool of registered voters. Kosher? 

Another Defendant goes to trial starting today in that horrible kidnapping, sexual assault murder case out of Penrods from several years ago. Judge Will Thomas presides. ASA Reid Ruben picks up where Abe Laeser left off. ASA Laura Adams has been on the case from the beginning. 

See You In Court. 






Sunday, September 09, 2012

NFL 2012 WEEK ONE

UPDATE: Here is the 4pm football update: The Dolphins kept it close for most of the first half and that had a lot of people nervous. But the Texans prevailed and Dore Louis went down bravely in defeat. 
The real shocker was REGIII and the Redskins upsetting the Saints (that was THE early season trend and this was a money make for Redskin bettors). And that means Angry Girl, Alan Kaiser, Dan Lurvey, DOM,  and Michael Vick, are all first week losers. Tannebaum's Twitter went down with the Bills (as did we in our picks). Meanwhile BTDT, Stephen Imasche, Brian Freedman, Fake Joel Brown, Fake Alex Michaels and 52nd Street Irwin, all survived close games with the Eagles, Vikings,  or the Lions. 
Still waiting on Adam Tebrugge to send in his pick.

Football Pool 2012 PDF

Well, here we go. The 2012 football season begins today in ernest at 1:00 pm.  The Dolphins march to their worst record in their history begins in Houston, Texas today. The 2012 suicide pool is posted below, and we made a mistake yesterday calling Miguel De La Over the 20111 winner, when everyone remembers it was Michael Feiler. And speaking of suicide,  Dore Louis commits it today by picking with his heart- the Dolphins, than his head-any of the 31 other teams. At least he is an exponentially better trial lawyer than football prognosticator. 

We will update this chart throughout the day. 33 players so far...32 left standing as we start the first Sunday of the season. The chart has been reformulated to be in a mostly alphabetical format.

Football Pool 2012 PDF

We cannot devote the time to making picks every week like we did through the 2010 season. But from time to time we will give you some insights on the games. Do with them what you will.

Our source for odds is USA Today/Covers dot com here.

Bills +3 and under 39. Go light on this. But the J..E..T..S  will implode. The question is only when? Buffalo brings in a great defense with the addition of Super-Mario Wiliiams. We like Buffalo here. The Bills were a dropped TD pass away from beating the Steelers late last season and knocking them out of the playoffs. The Bills are for real. 

NE at Tennessee. Titans + 5 at home. Titans Jake Locker is starting his second year. Tennessee has a good run game a solid D. Wanna have some fun? Take the money line.  +190, which means you get back a 190 for every 100 you lay. We're putting down a few shekels on the Titans, just for fun. If our guy in Vegas can get us +210, which is out there in some books, we might go as high a geezel (a dime).

Green Bay - 5 over San Fran. Take this for 300 Joel Browns.

Raiders -1 and under 47 against the Chargers. We like the under 47 for 300 Carson Palmers.

If you're a Philly fan, take the Eagles, lay the ten, leave the cannoli.  Browns starting a rookie QB and their rookie star RB is out with a knee injury. Update: Chris Mortensen just tweeted that Richardson is starting. The guy just had knee surgery.  Stay with the Eagles, although under 43 is also a play now. The Browns season is starting out like the way Judge Hirsch's summer ended: not great.

And just because we're not all about football, Obama got a convention bump in all of the polls. Romney did not. It's all down to two things: Does Israel (whose Prime Minister Netanyahu worked with Mitt in Massachusetts in the early 1980's and is a friend of Romney's) strike Iran before the election? Netanyahu does not enjoy great relations with the Obama administration, although an attack would be an unprecedented attempt to influence the US election. And can Romney capitalize on an Obama gaffe in one of the debates? Ronald Wilson Regan went into October trailing  James Earl Carter in all of the polls. Then they debated.....

Enjoy 10+ hours of football. See You In Court Monday. 




Saturday, September 08, 2012

10 THOUGHTS ON THE NFL 2012

SUICIDE POOL UPDATE FOR SATURDAY: Get your picks in by Sunday 12:59 pm unless you like the 4pm game, the 8pm game or one of the two MNF games. We're ready for some football.  We've got 31 players so far (still time to sign up) including defending Champion Miguel De La Over who insinuates that a repeat is a given and is working on analyzing next years draft for a three-peat. 
Football Pool 2012 PDF


Ten  thoughts about the new season:
1) Who will the Dolphins be drafting in the first pick of the 2013 draft, since they already have a QB and are facing a disastrous season?

2) Atlanta has a better team than Green Bay. But the Falcons underperform in the big games. Falcons go as far as their coaches take them (see#10).

3) The Texans almost made it to the Super Bowl last year with a third string QB and without Mario Williams for most of the season. They had the number 2 defense in the league last year. Watch out for them and take the under against the Dolphins in week one. 

4) The Tennessee Titans are another surprise team. Could go 12-4 and will fight the Texans for the divisional title. Bet the Titans early and often, including getting five at home against the cheaters. 

5) The J...E...T...S.. will open the season at 1-4 or 2-3. They will lose to the Steelers, Texans and 49ers.  They will beat the Fins. Only question is whether they beat Buffalo in week one- we think they lose to the Bills.Teebow that!

6) San Fran is the class of the NFC west. But stay away from them in non-divisional games. They just might not be as good as they think they are. 

7) Problem with the Eagles going all the way is that it all rests on the fragile shoulders of Michael Vick. Maybe that's why Philly is only -6 at the hapless Browns in week one. You have to factor in losing Vick every week. 

8) Rex Ryan annoys us. More importantly, his act is wearing thin and will continue to wear thin with a NY team that will underperform. 

9) When considering the o/u line early in the season, take your cue from the Giants/Cowboys. The defense is ahead at this point. 

10) Packers vs Ravens in Super bowl. Packs nip Falcons in NFC Championship game while Ravens bulldoze outmatched Texans.

This is our absolute favourite time of the year. Football. US Open Tennis. Sparkling beautiful weather. Enjoy! See you Monday. 

Thursday, September 06, 2012

UNCLE JOE WANTS YOU

SUICIDE POOL UPDATE: If you don't see your name, you haven't successfully registered. If you don't see your pick, send it again in a NEW email and don't reply to the old one. Good luck. We have a winner of our FIRST PERSON OUT. Clay Kaiser take a bow. In the history of the REGJB blog suicide pool, no one has ever gone out on the first Wednesday of the football season. 
Football Pool 2012 PDF

UPDATE: Perhaps the greatest amicus brief ever filed.  And only five pages. A must read!
Apple Amicus Brief 1



Joe Centorino is looking for volunteers for this worthy cause:

The Miami-Dade Commission on Ethics and Public Trust and the Miami-Dade County School Board have each passed resolutions endorsing this project, which will put hundreds of volunteers into Miami-Dade high school classrooms to speak on the importance of civic participation as an avenue to promoting more ethical government at all levels.  The date was chosen for its proximity to an important
Presidential election.  We are calling upon public officials, civic leaders and attorneys with significant civic involvement or government experience to join in this community conversation by sharing their knowledge and insight with the next generation of voters.

You may consider volunteering for the entire day or for any portion of the day, and we will place you in one or more high school classrooms for this event.  You may also indicate a school preference, which we will accommodate wherever possible.  While we will provide suggested talking points for all speakers, we are encouraging our volunteer speakers to draw upon their own stories and backgrounds in their presentations and to make an effort to connect personally with students.  This is a worthwhile, non-partisan project which will provide you with an opportunity to help improve the civic life of our community.

Sign up and volunteer by emailing Uncle Joe at Centori at Miamidade.gov  or at this website. 

TIMING IS EVERYTHING

Update: some very minor factual errors corrected below. 

"The 3rd DCA sits next to the FIU campus in Kendall and NOT at the crossroads of 12th street and 13th avenue..." 
which is sort of what this opinion -which everyone is talking about- from the 3rd seems to say. 

Or to put it another, simpler way: trial judges of equal jurisdiction DO NOT have the authority to modify a bond or conditions of release that have been set by another judge. 

The facts: When the opinion starts out: "Hall is a violent felony offender who was charged with one count of lewd and lascivious molestation on a child ages 12-16, aggravated battery with a deadly weapon, three counts of child abuse with no great bodily harm, and one count of harassing a victim/witness in a second-degree felony" you know you have a problem.

Hall pled to prison plus probation. Once released, Hall used that most criminally nefarious of networks- Facebook- to attempt to contact the 16 year old daughter of a former girlfriend.  Going before Judge Rebull, the prosecution  moved to revoke Hall's probation and have him held without bond  because of a 2009 permanent DV injunction prohibiting Hall from "directly or indirectly" attempting  to contact the victim. 

Judge Rebull granted the motion and Hall was taken into custody. The next day the defense team filed a motion to dismiss the affidavit and release Hall, arguing that the use of Facebook to contact the girl did not constitute even an indirect attempt to contact the victim. 

Timing is everything in life. If Kennedy wasn't in Dallas in November of 1963,  perhaps we wouldn't have had the Vietnam war. If Lincoln was tired and didn't want to go to the theater that fateful night,  then perhaps he would have finished his second term and enjoyed the peace he had finally achieved. And if Judge Rebull hadn't taken the day off the next day  (update: to attend a very important judicial conference/college/whatever) after ordering Hall taken into custody,  and if Judge Milton Hirsch hadn't thoughtfully agreed to sit in for Judge Rebull and cover his calendar (update: because he was the designated weekly emergency judge- and talk about bad timing with that!), then surely we wouldn't have the decision in Hall v. Ryan, et. al. 

Judge Hirsch released Hall, and the very next day, on the State's motion, Judge Rebull threw Hall back in the can.


"Rule 3.131(d)(1)(B), Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure, controls. This rule provides, in relevant part:
No judge or court of equal or inferior jurisdiction may modify or set a condition or release...
Judge Hirsch, the alternate judge in this case, was thus without the authority to alter Hall’s bail status under rule 3.131(d)(1)(B)....."
Moral of the Story: Kennedy and Lincoln should have stayed home and Judge Rebull should have gone to work the day after ordering Hall taken into custody for the first time. 
See You In Court. 




Wednesday, September 05, 2012

FOOTBALL POOL 2012

UPDATE: Take the Giants tonight and lay the 4. 

The football pool is heating up, with many of your favourite regulars, and a few newbies, all out to show they can pick one winning team a week. 
  Robin Faber and BTDT impressively sent picks for the entire season. We shall see if their confidence is borne out in their picks. 
Faber starts off with da Bears, BTDT the Lions, Jon Colby the Patriots, DOM the Saints, while Orlando Gonzalez picks the Bears. 
Rumpole is leaning heavily towards the Texans at home over the Dolphins, although the Vikes at home over the Jaguars seems a good pick as well. 

The following other players are signed up and ready to go: 52nd street Irwin (who's not out, but has limited access to a computer), Fake Alex Michaels, Juan Gonzalez, Orlando Rodriguez, Adam Tebrugge, Stephen Immasche, Peter Sautter, Clay Kaiser, Brian Freedman, Michael Grieco, Itikhar Memon (the most annoying name in the pool every year), Michael Feiler, Dustin Tischler, Marshall Dore Louis, Rick Freedman, Dan Lurvey, Fake Joel Brown, Angry Girl, Kenny Weisman, and The soon to be honorable Miguel De La Over. 

That's 25 players so far,  if you're counting at home. Remember the 2012 season kicks off Wednesday. 
Personally, we like the Texans at home over the struggling Dolphins. But that could change. 

Remember: the season opens Wednesday: Cowpokes at Giants. 

Have fun.

Lines we're watching to see how they move: Broncos -1 1/2 over Steelers;  Green Bay -5 over 49'ers;  Giants -4 over Dallas. 

Best gambling tip: As we have shown time and time again, the time to make money in the NFL is in the first three weeks of the season where you have identified the trends the betting public is not aware of. Find a team ready to break out and double down on it and laugh all the way to the bank. Watch the Bengals closely against the Ravens in week one. Even if they don't win, they could easily go 10-6 this year, while the Steelers, if the injury bug keeps up, could easily go 6-10. 




Tuesday, September 04, 2012

SUMMER IS OVER

NOT GUILTY!!. Congrats to Eddie O'Donnell. Well done. Well done indeed. 

VERDICT IS IN: David Ovalle from Herald tweeting the verdict. Stand by.....

UPDATE: The Jury is out in the Boating manslaughter case before Judge Walsh. 
Rae Shearn got the well deserved NG on Friday in the Jelmo Kirkland case. Self defense. Well done Ms. Shearn. Well done indeed. 

BREAKING: JOA....reserved. The judge neither granted nor denied the JOA. She reserved on the motion.  The case goes to the jury. As per @Davidovalle305 tweets. Follow him and never miss an important REGJB story again.

BREAKING: Judge Lisa Walsh hearing argument from both sides on the JOA argument on  the boating manslaughter case. @Davidovalle305 just tweeted around 1:45 pm that the Judge seemed on the verge of granting the motion. More as this story breaks.

Black Widow Update: Griselda Blanco: If you just can't get enough of the godmother of cocaine, check out this retrospective by Cocaine Cowboys director @billycorben here.

Welcome back. How was your Labor Day weekend? Now, as our Governor likes to say, Lets get to work. 

The REGJB should be positively crawling with new ASAs and PDs just chomping at the bit to speak on the record. Be nice. 

How did we miss the 100th Birthday of the Oreo in March? 

The Democratic Convention starts up this week. But more importantly, the NFL starts on Wednesday with the Cowpokes v. The Gints. Should be a nice match up, until the Cowpokes realize that Tony Romo is still their QB.  

David Ovalle tweeted that Jelmo Kirkland was acquitted of second degree murder late Friday before Judge Colodny. Anybody care to give a shout out to the defense attorney(s) that deserve a Rumpolian "well done"? 

Don't panic. Go organic. Read the whole article to see the benefits of organic fruits and meats. The headline is a bit misleading. 

There's a fascinating federal trial going on that is giving the jurors an inside look at the secretive Amish community. A series of attacks by a breakaway Amish sect on other Amish, in which men's beards and hair were cut against their will has turned from a simple assault and battery case into a federal hate crimes prosecution. 

This just in: At the Democratic National Convention, Arnold Schwarzenegger will be the surprise speaker just before President Obama. He will yell at an empty  table for several minutes before warning "I'll be back".  Really.  Go ahead. Make our day. 

Welcome back. 

See You In Court. 





Monday, September 03, 2012

GRISELDA BLANCO REPORTED MURDERED!

UPDATE: The BBC has confirmed that Blanco was assassinated. 

BREAKING. Griselda Blanco, the self described godmother of cocaine, and a woman who rained drugs and death on Miami throughout the 1970's and 1980's has been reported murdered in Medellin, Colombia. This news report is somewhat disjointed, so we will try and get some confirmation. 

The history of Miami includes many characters, some good, some bad. Griselda Blanco, as bad as she was, occupies a place in this town's history. Her murder, if she was indeed killed, does little to assuage  the wide swath of death and destruction she wrought in our town. 

Blanco's story was the centerpiece of director Billy Corbin's Cocaine Cowboys documentary.  If you new ASAs and PDs want to know the history of where you're working, Cocaine Cowboys is a good place to start. 

Thursday, August 30, 2012

ARE YOU READY FOR SOME FOOTBALL?

Update: Sad news. A Broward ASA arrested Friday for committing domestic violence against a Dade ASA- his wife. Nothing pleasant about personal problems being on display in the newspaper. 

The National Football League opens its season next Wednesday. Which means the world famous, award winning, set your-head-a-spinning-, rockin and rollin,  roof raisin, shocking and amazing Justice Building BLOG SUICIDE POOL IS BACK!

The rules are simple: pick one team that will win each week. The spread is not considered. Just pick one winner. BUT, once you use that team, you cannot use that team for the rest of the year. 

Send your picks by email to: fbpool12@gmail.com (the same address as last year). 

Rules: 1) No purchase necessary; 2) the time of your email governs your pick. If you send an email at 12:59:59 on a Sunday for the 1pm game, you're in. If you send it at 1:00:01, you're out for the 1pm game and have to make a pick for the 4pm game or the Monday night game. Remember: there is a full schedule of Thursday night games this year. 3) All decisions of the the blogger are final. 4) By entry into the pool you are agreeing to litigate any matters before the Honorable Judge Juan Ramirez, (Ret.), with his arbitration company, and you will be responsible for all costs. 
5) Emailed picks  sent to our regular email address (Howardroark21) will be replied to with this message :"Hey, idiot? How did you pass the bar? Can't you follow simple rules."  You will also be openly mocked on the blog for being a dope. 

Check you're email in box. If you played last year, you should have an email from fbpool12. Former Judge Jon Colby responded with alacrity. He is the first registered player for 2012.   

Labor Day Weekend is here!
Cold beer; cookouts, and perhaps the best news of all: The Republican Convention is OVAH!

Enjoy your long weekend. 
See you in court. 


Wednesday, August 29, 2012

NEW ORLEANS SOAKED

Isaac moved slowly over the gulf coast and New Orleans is flooded. Again. Because the large storm moved so slowly, many homeowners said that Isaac caused more damage than Katrina. 

The Republican convention in Tampa. *yawn*. There hasn't been a really good convention since the Republican 1980 convention when Reagan and Ford were negotiating in Michigan for a co-presidency "dream ticket."  That was a great convention to be a delegate at. 

Good News (except for our contentious reader "Angry Girl") A severe  low calorie diet does not lead to a longer life. 

George Zimmerman wins in the 5th DCA on his motion to disqualify the trial judge. Lesson: a judge should not encourage the prosecution to file additional charges:


Although many of the allegations in Zimmerman's motion, standing alone, do not meet the legal sufficiency test, and while this is admittedly a close call, upon careful review we find that the allegations, taken together, meet the threshold test of legal sufficiency. Accordingly, we direct the trial judge to enter an order of disqualification which requests the chief circuit judge to appoint a successor judge.
PETITION GRANTED. 

GEORGE COSTANZA, J,  CONCURS:
The South Florida blogger ably covers the civil decisions of the 3rd DCA, and on Wednesday he specifically covered this decision on a foreclosure fifteen years in the making, and Judge Schwartz's reluctant concurrence. But he failed to report on the final line: "As someone – probably either St. Thomas More or George Costanza – must have said, the law is the law. Notwithstanding the distasteful consequences of applying it in this case, it must be served."

One thing you can say about George Costanza, he was master of his domain. He won a contest. And in another context, Judge Schwartz is clearly the master of his domain (the sharply, smartly worded concurrence/dissent). 

Labor day weekend coming up. August will soon be over, thankfully. 
See You In Court. 

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

BACK TO THE GRIND

We are eagerly anticipating Tom Wolfe's new novel. Back to Blood, about a certain city that we all call home, is due to be released in October. 
As the weather stayed a lot worse Monday than anyone expected, is there any doubt that closing the state and federal courts was the right decision? 

The new PDs and ASAs have started, welcomed to our little world by tropical storm Isaac that kept them from exploring the wonders of south florida. A word to the wise to our new young friends: South Beach is enticing but it can lure you with tales of fast cars, sexy bodies, and easy fortunes. None of it is true. SOBE is best enjoyed in small doses. 

Now about court. It is as simple as this: Rumpole's First Rule of Being a Lawyer: It will take you a lifetime to earn a good reputation in the REGJB, and just one minute to ruin it. 
Let your word be your bond.  Be honest in your dealings with other lawyers and judges. When you prep your witnesses, give them one simple instruction: tell the truth. No one wins all their cases. No one case is worth a career or a bad reputation. When judges and lawyers talk about lawyers, they rarely speak about lawyers who never lose, mostly because no lawyer never loses. But they often talk about lawyers who are hard working, well prepared, and honest. Those traits will catch your supervisor's eyes before winning a trial will. 
Get used to losing. It provides a valuable experience. If you don't learn from your losses you will never get better. We lost our first three jury trials. We won our next sixty or so before a lesser came back.  Every case is an opportunity to learn your craft. 

One simple rule about trials. Put in about four or five hours of prep for every hour in court. If you are on the defense side, accept nothing, investigate everything. If the state has an expert, get their prior testimony. Get their college grades. Read their doctoral thesis. Go to the crime scene. Speak to your witnesses. Push and dig and dig and dig until you get the impeachment evidence you need. 
If you're a prosecutor, then you are doing justice. What an awesome and wonderful responsibility to have. But never forget that sometimes doing justice means dismissing a case when every cop and witness and victim is angry at you. Satisfying them is not worth the tragedy of convicting an innocent man or woman. 

So welcome young ASAs and PDs. And when you're down, and you're thinking you will never get the hang of it, and when you least expect it, a grizzled old lawyer may pull you aside in court and whisper in your ear "Kid, you've got talent. Don't give up." 
It happened to us. 

See you in court. 

Monday, August 27, 2012

WHEN THE PD SYSTEM BREAKS DOWN

The Nation looks at New Orleans, a city in which the Public Defender system has broken down. 

On April 18, 2011, New Orleans police arrested Clarence Jones, a 41-year-old black man. Clarence contends that he was walking with his cousin Keitha Hyde, running some errands around 11:30 am, when he ducked into an alley to relieve himself. “It was just an empty house, so I went in the backyard out of sight,” he says, talking to me via phone from jail—and when cops turned the corner, he looked guilty. But police contend that Clarence was climbing out a window with pliers in his left hand, apparently scrapping for metal or copper wiring in the gutted building. The cops arrested him and his cousin and took them to the Orleans Parish Prison. On May 13, nearly a month later, Clarence finally appeared before a magistrate in Orleans Parish Criminal Court, who arraigned him on the charge—simple burglary—and set his bail at $10,000 (before raising it four days later to $20,000).

More than sixteen months later, Clarence Jones is still in jail waiting for an attorney to be assigned to represent him. “It’s been hell back here,” he says, explaining that he is living, along with approximately 400 other prisoners, in oversized tents that fill the prison grounds. In the aftermath of Katrina, which flooded huge swaths of the massive Orleans Parish Prison seven years ago, circus-style tents were erected to “temporarily” house the inmates. Today, the tents are still housing prisoners on a patch of barren ground in the middle of the city.


Even worse, the Orleans Parish Prison—already notoriously violent—veered out of control as Jones languished there. Things got so bad that the US Marshals Service pulled its prisoners from the facility in March 2012. Then the Justice Department sent a letter to the New Orleans sheriff in April citing “alarming conditions” in the “violent and dangerous” prison. The detailed list of constitutional violations runs twenty-one pages. Clarence Jones puts it simply: “It’s like we animals. They’re just packing more and more people in. They got us packed to capacity. Lots of us have no attorney. Can’t do nothing but sit back here. We’re just stuck.”...
Clarence is one of 230 people sitting in limbo in the Orleans Parish Prison this summer after a $2 million budget shortfall forced the Orleans Parish public defender’s office to lay off twenty-seven employees, twenty-one of them lawyers. 

Rumpole says: Shocking. Bring on the Limited Registry. 

ISAAC'S AFTERMATH

Monday dawned muggy and rainy in Miami, with the back end of  Isaac's storm bands moving on shore bringing intense rains. This is no weather for school children to be out on the road commuting to school. The decision to close schools and courts was spot on. Better to be safe than sorry. 

THE STRUGGLE CONTINUES:
The struggle for civil rights, in various forms, continues throughout this country, as backward laws are struck down and oppressive societal norms fade in the face of popular cultural movements. Meet our latest hero: New Yorker Moira Johnson, whose courageous fight to give women the right to walk bare chested through New York continues. Her story (and some pics) are reported here at the Daily Beast.  Johnson's brave quest began, like so many of the civil rights struggles, when one day she simply  had enough. In January 2012, Johnson was in yoga studio and she was hot. And like some of her Y chromosome counterparts, she took off her shirt. It was in the greatest traditions of civil rights battles of the past: white and black college students sitting together at lunch counters in the south, or Rosa Parks refusing to give up her seat and go to the back of the bus. 
 Bravo! we say. The sharper legal eagles amongst our readers know that the right of women to walk topless in public in the Bare Big Apple was secured in the landmark 1992 case of People v. Santorelli and Schloss.  But as many of us remember, even after the civil rights acts of the 1960's were passed, it took many more years and legal cases before the simple act of voting or using a restroom or sipping from a water fountain in the south was not fraught with racial tension. 


Sometimes heroes emerge from the unlikeliest of places. Enjoy your day off. See you in court tomorrow, ready to roll. 


PS: On a completely "different" subject matter, Tampa's most venerable institutions await the Republican National Convention as per the Miami Herald. Personally, we've found that a nice roll of single dollar bills helps matters when in Tampa. "When in Rome..."

Saturday, August 25, 2012

STATE COURTS CLOSED MONDAY

AND NOW LAST, AND LEAST, MIAMI DADE STATE COURTS HAVE BEEN (apparently reluctantly) ORDERED CLOSED ON MONDAY. 

Federal court is closed. Read below. 

UPDATE: Neil Armstrong has died at age 82 following complications from cardiovascular surgery. 

MIAMI DADE SCHOOLS CLOSED MONDAY. No change on courts. So for all of you parents of school aged children who work in the court system, what can Brown do for you? But because public schools are closed, federal court is closed, as per Judge Moreno's "Inclement Weather Policy." ( (c) Chief Judge Moreno, 2012, all rights reserved. )

UPDATE: Our favourite federal judge (everyone should have one) Jack B. Weinstein of the Eastern District of New York (that's Brooklyn for the few people in Miami who don't come from NY) has ruled that Poker is a game of skill and thus poker rooms cannot be prosecuted under federal anti-gambling laws. From the Agent Orange Case in the early 1980's, to his outspoken opposition to minimum mandatory sentencing schemes, to his handling of the case against mafia crime boss Vinny the Chin (when the oft told joke in the Brooklyn courthouse was that the lord was seeing a psychiatrist because he thought he was Judge Weinstein kept making the rounds)  Jack B. Weinstein is a great, great judge. 

As dawn breaks over Miami Saturday, winds and rain lash our community and power outages are starting to be reported. TS Isaac is approaching Cuba and the Florida straits, where it is expected to strengthen. Hurricane warnings have been posted for the Florida Keys and a tropical storm watch for the east coast of Florida. 

And our 11th Judicial Circuit posted this notice that courts will be open on Monday. And so it goes. UPDATE: This notice states courts will be closed on Monday. The chief judge congratulates the Miami Heat on a well deserved victory and championship. 

Because they're so on top of things, there's also a notice governing the use of beepers in the courthouse. (not really). 

A BILLION TO APPLE
This minute by minute coverage of the verdict on the ATL blog is interesting, but it doesn't answer the question we all have after reviewing the billion dollar verdict Apple received Friday night: Siri- did Morrison and Foster and WillmerHale have a contingency fee recovery in their retainer with Apple? 

The Dolphins stink. 4-12 looks about right. Just enough wins to avoid the top three picks in the draft. And so it goes. 

Stay safe and dry. 


Friday, August 24, 2012

CRIME AND PUNISHMENT

In Oslo Norway on Friday a court found Anders Breivik sane and guilty for killing 77 people last year in Norway's worst peacetime atrocity. Breivik was sentenced to the maximum- 21 years in prison, although the sentence can be extended at a later date if he is found to be a danger to society. 

The most unusual aspect of this trial was that prosecutors argued that Breivik was insane, not responsible for his crimes, and should be hospitalized, while his defense attorneys argued (probably at their client's insistence) that he was sane. 

Breivik will be incarcerated in isolation in a three room cell, with an exercise area and a laptop computer that does not have access to the internet. 

A few thoughts: First: how would this have been handled in the United States? Predictably, the death penalty would have been sought and no prosecutor who wanted to keep their job would ever have argued that the defendant was insane. 
Secondly, incarceration would inevitably have been for at least life in prison and the defendant would have been left to rot and go insane in a 10 x 10 cell for 23 hours a day.

Killing 77 people makes such extreme punishment easy to mete out.  But perhaps something can be learned from Norway in this case. In the worst imaginable criminal act, their justice system had prosecutors advocating for what they believed to be the truth, not what the public demanded. The sentence handed out will be served by all appearances, in a humane manner. In short, Norway resisted the almost irresistible urge to be dragged down to this killer's brutal mentality and treat him the way he treated others. Norway maintained its dignity in one of its darkest hours. 

The length of the sentence in this case is something handed out on a daily basis by US judges to petty drug dealers with lengthy criminal records. In recent times in the US, only former Panamanian dictator Manuel Noriega was incarcerated in such a humane manner, and that was because international treaties required the United States to treat him better than it treats its own citizens. Of course the United States (federal and state governments) currently incarcerates over 2 million of its citizens, so there isn't much room in overcrowded prisons for humane treatment. 

We don't approve of the sentence in Norway. Nobody would argue that 21 years is sufficient punishment for killing 71 people. But if this is how Norway treats its worst offender, how does it treat the rest of its citizens when laws are violated? 

ISAAC: 5 AM Friday update:


Things are looking good for South Florida. However, we suggest postponing that trip to Key West this weekend. 

Thursday, August 23, 2012

A HELPING HAND

When you file a petition for cert to the United States Supreme Court, it helps when the NY Times editorializes that the court should take the case. From the NY Times Op Ed Prosecutorial Abuse: 


This case was brought against Dr. Ali Shaygan for allegedly dispensing drugs outside the scope of his medical practice. He was acquitted of all charges in 2009, after a four-week trial and jury deliberations of only three hours.
The trial judge awarded almost $602,000 to cover Dr. Shaygan’s lawyers’ fees and expenses and reprimanded the prosecutors, who had threatened a defense lawyer with a “seismic shift” if he asked the judge to suppress statements obtained from Dr. Shaygan in violation of his rights. When the defense lawyer went ahead with his request, the prosecution, in reprisal, increased the number of charges from 23 to 141. The judge, quite rightly, said the government had not acted in “good faith,” in addition to perpetrating other “conscious and deliberate wrongs.”
Lesson: When you mess with Mr. Markus, his publicity machine reaches into the upper levels of the NY Times. 
UPDATED PROBABILITY CONE: As of 5 am Friday:
We're not out out of the woods yet, but you should postpone  that trip to Key West.




Broward has issued an email alert on the storm:
We are tracking the current storm activity. In the event of a tropical storm or hurricane approaching our area we will make a decision regarding closure. Should Broward come under a tropical storm or hurricane warning, the closure information will be posted on our website at www.17th.flcourts.org 

Judge Peter M. Weinstein
17th Judicial Circuit Court

Our Chief Judge is considering closing courts for the Heat's victory parade.  

You can follow the 11th judicial circuit on twitter @MiamiDadeCourts. Latest Tweet: "Sad to see Dolphin coaching great Don Shula retire."