JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG

WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL RICHARD E GERSTEIN JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG. THIS BLOG IS DEDICATED TO JUSTICE BUILDING RUMOR, HUMOR, AND A DISCUSSION ABOUT AND BETWEEN THE JUDGES, LAWYERS AND THE DEDICATED SUPPORT STAFF, CLERKS, COURT REPORTERS, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS WHO LABOR IN THE WORLD OF MIAMI'S CRIMINAL JUSTICE. POST YOUR COMMENTS, OR SEND RUMPOLE A PRIVATE EMAIL AT HOWARDROARK21@GMAIL.COM. Winner of the prestigious Cushing Left Anterior Descending Artery Award.
Showing posts with label Rumpole's rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rumpole's rules. Show all posts

Monday, December 12, 2022

READY FOR TRIAL?

 If you follow Rumpole's Rules For Trials  ((c) 2010 all rights reserved) then you know a few things. Avoid Friday Verdicts; NEVER EVER EVER allow a case to be set for trial in the first week of January; and ...

always try to try a case in the last two weeks of December. 

Unlike the first week of January, everyone is in a good mood, especially the jurors, who are more likely to overlook a little mistake (like "I thought the billing codes for medicare were correct, darn it"). 

But alas, our secret is out:

FYI from the Jury Pool -
 
Because the holidays are observed on Monday (12/26) and (1/2), we will be bringing in jurors on Tues, Wed and Thurs of both weeks.  There will be no jurors on Friday 12/30 and 1/6.

Monday, March 01, 2021

RUMPOLE'S RULES FOR COURT APPEARANCES

 From time to time we expound upon our wisdom, gained from years in the crucible. We are gratified, for example, that some notable trial judges have seized upon our rules for Judges  and adopted our rule that when a lawyer says she is going on vacation the judge does her no favors by setting the trial for the week she gets back. 

And now, just to show that we are even handed (certain Judges are spitting up their coffee at this moment) we present some common sense rules for lawyers when appearing in Court, via Zoom or in person. 

There really is only two rules that matter at all. It is the first rule (#1) , the last rule (#10), and together they encompass every other rule: 

RUMPOLE'S RULE #1: DO NOT BE LATE FOR COURT. A famous football coach had a rule that being early for an 8 am meeting was being in the room at 7:30; being on time was being in the room at 7:45 and being late was being in the room any time after 7:50 and no one should dare walk through the door at 8. The same goes for lawyers. You want to let a judge know you are professional and care about the client and the case? Show up early. Every hearing, every time. Everything else flows from that. 

RULE#2: Even in times of Zoom, men wear a jacket and tie and women wear whatever it is that they wear that is a respectful business suit. You are showing respect for the position and the dignity of the court. On Zoom you should never wear shorts and a jacket and tie. Wear a full suit, including shinned shoes. Personal preparation is a pre-condition to client preparation. 

RULE 3: Be prepared. Have the documents already out. Have your argument written down, no matter how simple. Don't read from it, but the simple five minutes preparation of writing "We are asking for a continuance because the state was late with discovery and we need more time" is a away of preparing. When was discovery served the judge may ask? Hold up the document you have already located with a time stamp. Fumbling through a file makes you look unprepared and no judge should tolerate that. 

RULE4: Always stand when addressing the Court, even when on zoom. It shows respect for the position of the Judge. Period. No discussion. 

RULE5: Always be respectful to opposing counsel. If they were late in discovery but sent it after you asked, make sure you tell the judge that. If you have a history with the lawyer, tell the judge that as well. "Discovery was late but I know counsel for the state and she is always diligent about her responsibilities ..." 

RULE6: Always address Court personnel and be respectful and tell the Judge how the clerk or court reporter helped you find something just before court started. Always thank corrections officers for helping with your client. 

RULE7: Spend time with your client before and after every hearing. Let them know what to expect and afterwards what occurred. Follow that up with an email. Most lawyers get in trouble with the Bar for not keeping the client informed. Email ends that problem pure and simple. 

RULE8: Never never never never surrender. As Mr. Markus says, "You cannot win a plea." 

RULE9: See rules 1, 8 & 10. They are  that important.  

RULE10: Never be anything other than 100% candid with the Court. It takes a lifetime to build a reputation and one moment to lose it. Do prevaricate, equivocate, or any other "ocate". Just tell the truth and if you cannot do so- tell the Court you cannot answer the question. One lie...one exaggeration, one miscommunication is all it takes to lose a judge, lose a case, and lose your reputation. 

Corollary: Judge's often have a short amount of time to grasp what are many times complicated sets of facts. A difficult job for the brightest amongst us (add the gratuitous shot at the bench here)...  So it stands to reason that some Judges who can't get all the facts down may well feel themselves drawn to the advocate that appears more levelheaded and more reasonable. No Judge gets intimidated by a lawyer who yells and engages in histrionics. In fact such actions are more likely to get them to stop listening to you. 

If you want to be a better lawyer and lay the foundations for success, start with our rules. 

Monday, January 04, 2021

2021 WEEK ONE

 Longtime and careful blog readers know that Rumpole's number one, inviolate rule of trials is to never ever ever allow a case to be set for trial during the first week of the New Year. Avoid the first two or three weeks of January if at all possible. 

The rule is based on years of experience. Watching colleagues and their clients go down in flames and judges issuing sentences well above the norm. 

There are multiple reasons for this. First and foremost is that Judges and Prosecutors spend the holiday weeks off during December pondering the prior year. And most of them reached the conclusion that they were too soft on defendants, which in turn allowed too many defendants to go to trial. And this of course, created more work than Judges want. So, as sure as Summer follows Spring, judges put their New Year's resolution into effect during the first one or two trials in January. "Let the word go forth" they fantasize saying, "Things are changing around here. You proceed to trial at your own risk. No more Ms. Nice Gal in these here parts." 

Of course as sure as Fall follows Summer, these Judges will- Casablanca like- deny the existence of a "trial tax" : "We are shocked! Shocked to learn that defendants are uniformly sentenced to a higher term of years after trial than before trial. Surely, if this is so it is because we, as Judges, "learned" more about the case, and not because we punished the defendant for going to trial and losing. Of course the Constitution forbids such a punishment."

State Court practitioners may wish to cite this case at appropriate times. We generally pull a dogeared copy of Wilson v. State from our battered briefcase right after the State says something like "the plea offer is withdrawn and the State is seeking the max sentence after trial." Acting stunned, we lift a copy of Wilson into the air and reply "Surely the prosecution is not telling this court that they will ask the court to punish the defendant for exercising his right to a trial by jury."

We also recognize that the constitutional right at issue in this case is not the defendant's right to appeal his conviction or sentence but, rather, the defendant's constitutional right to a jury trial. However, just as a trial judge cannot punish a defendant for exercising his or her appellate rights, the law is clear that any judicially imposed penalty which needlessly discourages assertion of the Fifth Amendment right not to plead guilty and deters the exercise of the Sixth Amendment right to demand a jury trial is patently unconstitutional

Wilson v. State, 845 So. 2d 142, 150 (Fla. 2003)

The less serious, but still relevant concern, is that who wants to spend the Christmas and New Years holidays preparing a case for trial? 

2021 is of course different. There are no trials this first week of January. But, like a vaccine, they are on the horizon. So it may be time to open the closet, bush those suits, shine those shoes, press those shirts and tie those ties. Trials are coming back. 

Just not during the first week of the New Year. 


Tuesday, December 31, 2019

RUMPOLES RULES FOR THE NEW YEAR

First, congrats to the 2019 Justice Building Blog Fantasy Football Champion Gary Bass, who bested Rumpole over the last two weeks. While not making an excuse, we did lose our top two RBs to injuries for the finals, as well as a starting TE. But injuries are part of the game and give Mr. Bass credit for snagging the QB we dropped earlier in the year- Jameis Winston from Tampa Bay. He was a big part of Mr. Bass's run to the championship. We have made the finals for the last two years, and won last year (our ability to brag officially ended on Sunday so Judge De La O can now rest easy). 
See you in 2020 Mr. Bass. 

Rules for the new year. 

1) No more Merry Christmas. That ended over this past weekend.

2) You can say "Happy New Year" through Sunday, and at five days that's stretching it. If you see us in the courthouse Monday (and you won't-see below) and say "Happy New Year" we will ignore you and keep on walking. 

We have a few rules for trials. We don't like Friday afternoon verdicts. They tend to be bad.  We don't believe in coincidences. It's usually not happenstance when two bad things happen to your client in a case.  As Ian Fleming, the creator of James Bond, once wrote- Once is a mistake, twice is happenstance, and the third is enemy action. 

But our number one rule for criminal defense attorneys, and this is inviolate, is do not- under any circumstances, allow a case to be set for trial for the first week of the new year. There are many factors at play during week one of the new year, and all of them bad. 

First, prosecutors have returned from vacation, refreshed and raring to go and one of their resolutions is to "get tough on crime". 

Second, and more ominously, Judges have returned from time off. And to the limited extent any of them engage in serious introspection, they have also decided that their case load is too high and they have the reputation of being too lenient. So, within the dark crevices of their black robes and hearts, they have decided  the best way to get people to plead and lower the case load  is to slam a few defendants right out of the box in the new year. The word will get out, lawyers (not your blogger) will fold their tents and plead their clients guilty. 

All of this leads to the inescapable conclusion to NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES allow a court to set your client's case for trial during the first week of the new year. Schedule surgery. Get married or divorced or both. Take you holiday vacation late. Donate blood. Volunteer for Lawyers without Borders. Do something. Do anything but make yourself unavailable during that first week of the new year. 

You ignore Rumpole's advice at your own peril.   

Happy New Year. We will be back in town sometime around January 15, 2020.