JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG

WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL RICHARD E GERSTEIN JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG. THIS BLOG IS DEDICATED TO JUSTICE BUILDING RUMOR, HUMOR, AND A DISCUSSION ABOUT AND BETWEEN THE JUDGES, LAWYERS AND THE DEDICATED SUPPORT STAFF, CLERKS, COURT REPORTERS, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS WHO LABOR IN THE WORLD OF MIAMI'S CRIMINAL JUSTICE. POST YOUR COMMENTS, OR SEND RUMPOLE A PRIVATE EMAIL AT HOWARDROARK21@GMAIL.COM. Winner of the prestigious Cushing Left Anterior Descending Artery Award.

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

BEST CANDY AND SCARY JUDGES

 First up is the never say die Tampa Rays who won a thriller in extra innings late Tuesday night and are still alive, Game five is next up Wednesday night, and if they win this one, our Rays in the series bet is still alive and pitching. 

This is the great Halloween year, when the day falls on Saturday. Perfect for parties we would never attend as a misanthropic blogger and longer hours for Trick and Treaters whose plaintive cries for candy we will not answer.  (We might leave out a bowl....we'll see). 

Our first question is what is your Favourite Halloween Candy?  Our Who is the Scariest Judge question is below. Don't miss it. 

Grumpy and old, we like old time favourites. 

M&M's- plain and peanut depending on our mood. Reese's Pieces and Peanut Butter Cups. A cold Nestles Crunch in the fridge. Ditto Kit Kats cold and snappy. Candy Corn when all the other candy is gone. 

Send us your picks and we will post them. 

Our fav Halloween movies? American Werewolf in London, followed by the Black and White Classics Abbott And Costello Meet Frankenstein  (with Bela Lugosi as Dracula!! who steals every scene he's in), followed by all the other Meets including Abbott and Costello Meet The Invisible Man...Meet The Mummy... Meet Dr. Jekyl & Mr. Hyde. 

They don't make movies like those anymore.  



If you want more Halloween stuff, with an REGJB slant, answer this: Who was/is  the scariest judge you appeared before? 

Now be nice here- don't attack anyone. What we are asking is which judge scared/scares  you? 

We will start. As a young lawyer County Court Judge Alfred Nesbitt (who was one of the first to wear coloured robes on the bench) made our knees a bit weak before we took a deep breath and walked into the courtroom. Ditto Judge Ellen Morphonious who called us, and most everyone Pal - even in front of the jury. 

And of course, 3rd DCA Judge Alan Schwartz, who was a giant on that bench and inspired terror in many a lawyer is on our list. Our first encounter with him ended with a brusque "Sit down. You Lost."  But we kept plugging on and when he would sit on the circuit bench in our REGJB we got to know him over coffee in the Pickle Barrell and became friends, and it was a friendship we valued. 

Remember- be nice- who scared you is the topic. Nasty comments will wither and die next to the bad Halloween candy like Sour Patch. 

Yuck


35 comments:

DS said...

Phil Davis when he was coked up on the bench, had the bailiff throw me out of his courtroom, over a stupid objection that I made to make the client happy. I expected the Judge to just say denied, but he found me in contempt and threw me out of the courtroom. But 2 weeks later the Feds raided his chambers with a warrant and arrested him so all balanced in the end

Anonymous said...

Scariest judge: VENZER. Nobody is even close.

Anonymous said...

Chocolate favorites are Reese's and M&Ms. For non-chocolate candy, I've been liking those nerd gummy clusters. And I'm not 5 years old. But they have a good mix of sweet and sour, gummy and crunchy.

Rumpole said...

Don’t see your comment ? It’s because you can’t read and follow instructions. Do not attack people and call them names like a_ hole. That isn’t going to get you a prestigious posting of your comment on this award winning blog.

Anonymous said...

Who are you to judge a judge?

Anonymous said...

Lacey Collier in the Northern District in Pensacola. I was trying a plaintiff’s side civil case and my witness was late. I asked for a brief continuance and Judge Collier turned to the jury and said “it appears plaintiff is resting.” The jury was immediately treated to a dramatic reading of pointless deposition testimony until the witness finally showed up. That’s an example but he was terrifying and great once you understood his rules.

Anonymous said...

That’s a great story

Anonymous said...

Rump can we get a list of the scariest prosecutors? It’s a trick question. See non are scary but some are obnoxious.

Anonymous said...

Stanley Marcus was scary smart. I was intimidated by his intellect.

Anonymous said...

Alan Schwartz. But he made me a better lawyer.

Anonymous said...

Remember Judge Stan Blake was rebuked for wearing a death outfit on the bench in criminal division.

Anonymous said...

The Trialmaster has NEVER been "scared" by any judge, state or federal.

CAPTAIN JUSTICE said...

THE CAPTAIN REPORTS:

SHOCKING NEWS! (WELL, NOT REALLY) .....

It saddens me to report that, for the first time since the last time, Governor DeathSantis has ONCE AGAIN failed to comply with the Florida Constitution.

You know, that pesky little document he took a solemn oath to support, protect, and defend when he assumed office.

Apparently, in Tallahassee, constitutional deadlines are merely suggestions.

Our self-proclaimed Rule of Law Governor, presiding over the Free State of Florida, where DEI comes to die, has once again demonstrated that the Rule of Law apparently applies to everyone EXCEPT the Governor himself.

On August 28, 2026, the Eleventh Circuit Judicial Nominating Commission certified its nominees to the Governor for FOUR judicial vacancies in Miami-Dade County: one Circuit Court seat and three County Court seats.

The Florida Constitution gave him 60 days to make those appointments.

DEADLINE: Tuesday, October 27, 2026.

APPOINTMENTS MADE: ZERO.

And, once again, not a peep from Tallahassee.

Perhaps someone should remind the Governor that the Florida Constitution says "SHALL," not "WHENEVER YOU GET AROUND TO IT."

The constitutional clock has expired. The Captain's clock is now ticking.

CAPTAIN OUT .....

Anonymous said...

Darth Pedro.

Anonymous said...

Rump, im shocked you dont like British sweets?! Flake, Twirl, Chocolate Buttons.... mmmm

Anonymous said...

Only if you’re soft…

Anonymous said...

Judge Jon Gordon.

Anonymous said...

Katie Pooler always had a dish of candy for those at the bench. Good candy. Nice touch.

Anonymous said...

No one intimidates me

Anonymous said...

No, I agree that Venzer is the scariest by far. When you walk in there you pray she's not in a bad mood already.

Anonymous said...

Best candy? Many to choose from.
But worst candy? Candy corn. By far.
Number 10 GI.

Anonymous said...

Venzer is the furthest thing from scary. What’s scary are the judges who don’t know anything about the law and don’t read motions. We all know who..

Anonymous said...

Judge Jack Block in South Dade. Anyone appear before him? Rough.

Anonymous said...

I like Payday and Baby Ruth.

Rumpole said...

No love for Kit Kats Twix M&Ms and Nestle’s crunch. Sad.

Fake Joel Denaro said...

Judge Lawrence King …in South Dade. Not scary to lawyers. But, to the defendants on the DWLS calendar. He would send his bailiff out to watch who drove to court. He would also ask people how did you get to court? Then he would have them take a seat in the box if they responded they drove and wait for someone to get them. It’s pretty scary if you ask me.

David Raben said...

Harvey Baxter!

Anonymous said...

100% ... Very smart and could be cruel.

Anonymous said...

I liked Jack. I think he was lonesome down there and enjoyed seeing downtown lawyers he knew.

Anonymous said...

Exactly what award has this blog won?

Anonymous said...

I was a clerk for 35 years. Non scared me.

Rumpole said...

So many that there’s not really room or time to list them all. But for example the the Actuarial Association’s prestigious Myron R Frome Best Legal Blogs was a recent big one. As was the National Academy of Anonymous Bloggers 20 Years Plus Blogging award. These are two of several dozen. Why do you care ?

Anonymous said...

Didn't really. Was just making conversation. Apparently I touched a nerve. My bad.

Anonymous said...

I scared plenty though.

Phil Maniatty said...

Judge King wasn't the first one to do that in Cutler Ridge. Judge Dick C.P. Lantz used to do that in 1976, but had the cops waiting to testify in other cases follow the defendants to the parking lot.