Seems like the feds have a point... "bad hombres" and all that running wild.But there's this little, tiny, insy-winsy thing called the Tenth Amendment. And here is what Judge Hirsch had to say about that:
"No doubt the limitations imposed by the tenth amendment, like so many limitations imposed by the Constitution, are a source of frustration to those who dream of wielding power in unprecedented ways or to unprecedented degrees. But America was not made for those who dream of power. America was made for those with the power to dream."
Here is the entire order for President
Well done Judge Hirsch, Well done indeed.
Lacroix Habeas Order by Anonymous espiON9E on Scribd
From Occupied America...Fight the Power, which Judge Hirsch did so admirably today.
There is no better ACADEMIC Judge on the bench than Judge Milton Hirsch. His orders are the finest, most interesting, most intellectual and he follows the law. He is a SCHOLAR of the Constitution. The other judges on the criminal bench know very little compared to him.
ReplyDeleteThe new Judges in the Criminal Division could take lessons on writing orders, knowing the law and being prepared by just sitting in on Judge Hirsch.
CJ Milton Hirsch's order in this case lacks the usual, and highly anticipated, plethora of learned words of his previous magistral opinions. Nonetheless, our disappointment is tempered by the inclusion of illustrious words such as "Exegesis", "Bailiwick", "Satrapies" and "Illimitable" within the main text of the opinion and quotes from Holy Writ and from the Bard in Richard III within the footnotes.
ReplyDeleteUmmm.... you know that's actually the County's response right, and not Hirsch's order?
ReplyDeleteWhich, much like the pompous one's last foray into hearing himself write (remember the mens rea cocaine cases?) is bound to end in a benchslap.
This is great stuff from two great minds. I applaud Judge Hirsch and Philip Reizenstein who had the clarity to see this issue as a violation of the Tenth amendment. I am proud to be a member of a profession inhabited by men like these.
ReplyDeleteKudos to Judge Hirsch!
ReplyDeleteWell done Phil.
ReplyDeleteWaiting for the dribble of "MAGA posts to come in...
ReplyDeleteWell said by Juan Gonzalez. We are truly blessed to have people in our profession who have no fear. The pursuit of justice is not for the timid.
ReplyDeleteTheodore G. Mastos
Well said by Juan Gonzalez. I, too, am proud to be a part of a profession in which people have no fear. The search for justice is not for the timid and faint of heart. Besides, getting blasted in a Trump tweet will be a badge of honor.
ReplyDeleteJudge Hirsch has more brains and courage than anyone else on the criminal bench. Those who mock him, including the 3DCA, are jealous cowardly half-wits. Judge Hirsch represents the majestic possibilities of the law. I feel proud to have practiced before him.
ReplyDelete