WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL RICHARD E GERSTEIN JUSTICE BUILDING BLOG. THIS BLOG IS DEDICATED TO JUSTICE BUILDING RUMOR, HUMOR, AND A DISCUSSION ABOUT AND BETWEEN THE JUDGES, LAWYERS AND THE DEDICATED SUPPORT STAFF, CLERKS, COURT REPORTERS, AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICERS WHO LABOR IN THE WORLD OF MIAMI'S CRIMINAL JUSTICE. THIS BLOG HAS BEEN CALLED "THE DEFINITIVE BLOG ON MIAMI CRIMINAL LAW" BY THE NY TIMES, THE WASHINGTON POST, THE POPE, AND DONALD TRUMP WHO ALSO ONCE SAID IT WAS "REALLY GREAT". POST YOUR COMMENTS, OR SEND RUMPOLE A PRIVATE EMAIL AT HOWARDROARK21@GMAIL.COM

Tuesday, October 03, 2017

FIRST TUESDAY IN OCTOBER

Monday was the first Monday in October.
Some grow-up waiting for opening day in baseball. Others spend their childhood  waiting for the autumnal smells and sounds and the cooler weather that signals the start of football season. 
For legal beagles like our fellow federal blogger, it was the first Monday in October that heralded the start of the new Supreme Court season that was circled on his calendar. While friends traded Baseball cards, he read the NLRB opinions of Douglas and Fortas.

This season started, unlike last year, with a full contingent of Supreme Court Justices. You will remember that the court operated for some time with eight justices, because of the "McConnell Law" which states "No justice shall be confirmed if nominated by a democratic president beyond thirty days in office of the new president's first term"- the reason behind the law being that after 30 days in office, it's better to wait four or eight years so the will of the people in a new presidential election can determine who can serve on the court. 

Did you know? That when Chief Justice Fred Vinson  died, President Eisenhower,  made a "recess appointment" of new Chief Justice Earl Warren in September, 1953? Warren served on the court as the term began in October, and then was confirmed by the Senate in January, 1954.

Did you also know that Warren, governor of California, was Dewey's running mate against Truman in 1948?

Did you also know that at the Republican Convention in 1952, Warren was California's favourite son, and was angling for the Vice President's spot on the ticket with Ike, before Nixon- the senator from California outmaneuvered him? Warren never forgave Nixon, and in 1952 privately and presciently called him "a crook and a thief"?   

This year's first day of the new term saw the re-argument of Sessions v. Dimaya, which was argued last year and resulted in a 4-4 decision. The case involves the question of what is a violent felony that requires the deportation of an immigrant? 
Dimaya was convicted of a residential burglary. "Out you go!"  said the Department of Homeland Deportations.
But citing a Scalia opinion in a similar case where the late Justice held that the Armed Career Criminal Act was void for vagueness,  Dimaya challenged the law. 

All eyes were on the new kid on the bench. Justice Gorsuch seemed skeptical of the Government's case. Judge G felt the law, which set up "categories" of crimes, rather than using specific lists,  forced judges to do the work of legislators. 

And we all know that there is no better way to anger the Federalist Society, which oversees all opinions of the Supreme Court, than to say "a judge is legislating"!

From Occupied and bullet-ridden America, Fight the Power!



6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Did you know that Justice Byron White (a JFK appointee) is the only justice ever to have led the NFL in rushing and been a college All American? Did you know that Justice John Rutledge was nominated by George Washington to replace John Jay as Chief Justice but attempted suicide and had his nomination withdrawn?

Anonymous said...

What happened to the South Florida lawyers blog?

Anonymous said...

Did you know? And here is another one that I read in "A Well Paid Slave," the saga of Curt Flood and the reserve clause. Justice Arthur Goldberg resigned from the Supreme Court in I think 1966. He was then appointed as US Ambassador to the UN, a major step down. The reason? To make way for the (failed) appointment of Abe Fortas, an LBJ crony. But what is not known is that LBJ promised Goldberg the VP slot in '68 in exchange for his going along with these shenanigans. Goldberg had to have known that LBJ was slick enough to pull the rug out from under him. Goldberg ran for governor against Rockefeller in '70 and lost.

Anonymous said...

I just got another newsletter from a law firm. I guess the Fla. Bar attorney list is easy to buy.

Guys, get real. Do you really think I need to get constant emails and a newsletter from some lawyer I see in court who actually competes with me to get cases telling me how great he or she is?

Do you really think I care what kind of cases you are working on?

I get two a day some days.

CUT IT OUT!

Anonymous said...

Are we to assume that notwithstanding the fact that Gorsuch asked a pro-defense question that he is still a bad guy? Do you have any idea how offensive your knee-jerk, left wing, "progressive" crap is? I even prefer reading your football bullshit over your leftwing crap. PEOPLE ARE DYING!

Anonymous said...

Liberal logic. They just don't get it.